What has the Appeals Board decided in CRPS cases?

California's Workers' Compensation Appeals Board has repeatedly upheld complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) diagnoses and ratings against challenges based on the AMA Guides. This page lists six panel decisions from 2021 to 2026 and four published Court of Appeal opinions. Workers kept or enlarged their awards in eight. One was denied total disability, and one lost a constitutional challenge.

A painted hard hat and work gloves with wild grasses.

Which California decisions on CRPS does this page cover?

This page covers ten decisions in California workers' compensation cases involving complex regional pain syndrome or its former name, reflex sympathetic dystrophy. Six are panel decisions of the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, and four are published opinions of the California Court of Appeal reviewing the Board. Each was opened and read at the linked address. The list is a set of located decisions, not a count of every CRPS ruling. Dollar amounts are left out. Court decisions in injury lawsuits are listed separately on the page about California court decisions on CRPS.

How much weight does each kind of decision carry?

The weight depends on the forum. A published Court of Appeal opinion binds the Appeals Board and its judges. An en banc decision of the Appeals Board is, in the Board's words, "binding precedent on all Appeals Board panels" and workers' compensation judges. A panel decision resolves a single case. The Board explained in Vigil v. County of Kern (2024) that panel decisions "are not binding precedent" but "are citable authority," and added: "Practitioners should proceed with caution when citing to a panel decision and verify its subsequent history." All six CRPS decisions from the Board on this page are panel decisions.

What did Appeals Board panels decide in CRPS cases in 2021?

Two panel decisions from 2021 ruled on petitions for reconsideration of a trial judge's award. The employer petitioned in Scatena, and the worker petitioned in Wilson.

Workers' Compensation Appeals Board panel decisions involving CRPS, 2021
DecisionDate and forumWhat was decidedResult for the worker
Scatena v. Tower of HillsboroughFebruary 9, 2021. Appeals Board panel (ADJ12221781)A police officer's CRPS of the right arm was proved by medical evidence although the evaluator did not document 8 of the 11 criteria in the AMA Guides. The 73 percent rating stood.Won. The employer's petition was denied.
Wilson v. Kohls Department StoreDecember 6, 2021. Appeals Board panel (ADJ10902155)A retail clerk with CRPS of the left ankle was not permanently totally disabled. Apportionment was removed and the award rose from 78 to 87 percent.Lost on total disability. Won a higher partial award.

Which 2024 panel decisions found a worker with CRPS totally disabled?

Two 2024 panel decisions left 100 percent awards in place after the employer petitioned for reconsideration.

Workers' Compensation Appeals Board panel decisions affirming permanent total disability for CRPS, 2024
DecisionDate and forumWhat was decidedResult for the worker
Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and RehabilitationFebruary 20, 2024. Appeals Board panel (ADJ9352174)A supervising cook's CRPS of the right arm was properly rated by analogy to loss of the arm, and psychiatric and dental impairments were properly added.Won. The employer's petition was denied.
Fanning v. Gelsons MarketApril 8, 2024. Appeals Board panel (ADJ10862354)A deli cutter with CRPS of both hands and arms was totally disabled on the orthopedic evidence. Apportionment to an earlier CRPS episode was rejected.Won. Total disability was affirmed.

Which panel decisions from 2024 to 2026 upheld a CRPS rating method?

Two panel decisions denied employer petitions that attacked the way the evaluating physician diagnosed and rated CRPS.

Workers' Compensation Appeals Board panel decisions upholding CRPS ratings, 2024 to 2026
DecisionDate and forumWhat was decidedResult for the worker
Garibay v. Scientific Drilling InternationalMarch 15, 2024. Appeals Board panel (ADJ15533334)A device assembler's CRPS was a compensable consequence of a thumb injury. The AMA Guides measure impairment and are not used to diagnose. The 65 percent award stood.Won. The employer's petition was denied.
Barreto v. City of VallejoMarch 12, 2026. Appeals Board panel (ADJ13057169)A police officer's CRPS of the right leg was rated with a station and gait table. The agreed evaluator's addition of impairments was upheld, for 62 percent.Won. The employer's petition was denied.

What did the panels decide about how CRPS is diagnosed?

The panels held that the AMA Guides do not control the diagnosis. In Scatena and Garibay, employers argued that CRPS could not be rated unless the evaluator found at least eight of the 11 criteria in the Guides. The Board rejected the argument both times. Garibay states that "the AMA Guides are not used for the purpose of diagnosing an injury." In Scatena and Wilson, physicians relied on the Budapest criteria. In Barreto, the Board upheld an evaluator who did not use them, writing that the Budapest criteria do "not close the door on other avenues for diagnoses." The page on the permanent disability rating has the details.

What have California appellate courts decided in CRPS workers' compensation cases?

Four published Court of Appeal opinions involve a worker with CRPS or reflex sympathetic dystrophy.

Published California Court of Appeal opinions in workers' compensation cases involving CRPS or RSD
DecisionDate and forumWhat was decidedResult for the worker
Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd., 12 Cal.App.5th 12492017. Court of Appeal, Second DistrictTotal disability from CRPS after surgery for a work condition is not apportioned.Won. The apportioned award was annulled.
Pearson Ford v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Hernandez), 16 Cal.App.5th 8892017. Court of Appeal, Fourth DistrictA fraud conviction did not bar benefits proved by evidence independent of the fraud.Won. The 70 percent award was affirmed.
Stevens v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd., 241 Cal.App.4th 10742015. Court of Appeal, First DistrictIndependent medical review of treatment denials is constitutional.Lost the constitutional challenge. Won a limited remand.
Matea v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd., 144 Cal.App.4th 14352006. Court of Appeal, Sixth DistrictFalling lumber was a sudden and extraordinary employment condition, so the six-month rule did not bar a psychiatric claim.Won. The Board's decision was annulled.

What did the Court of Appeal decide about CRPS caused by surgery?

Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) held that an employer cannot apportion disability that medical treatment of a work injury caused. A Costco employee had carpal tunnel surgery, developed CRPS and never returned to work. The Appeals Board reduced her total disability award by 10 percent, the share of her carpal tunnel condition that was not industrial. The Court of Appeal annulled that decision. It wrote that workers' compensation law "relieves Costco of liability for any negligence in the provision of the medical treatment that led to petitioner's CRPS. It does not relieve Costco of the obligation to compensate petitioner for this disability without apportionment."

What did the Court of Appeal decide about surveillance and fraud?

Pearson Ford v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) held that a fraud conviction does not automatically end a claim. A worker with a crushed finger was later found to have regional pain syndrome. An investigator filmed him, and he pleaded guilty to one misdemeanor count of workers' compensation fraud. The agreed medical examiner reviewed the videos and still found permanent disability. The Court of Appeal affirmed the award, stating that where, "independent of any fraud, a worker is able to establish his or her entitlement to benefits, benefits may be awarded."

What did the Court of Appeal decide about treatment denials?

Stevens v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2015) upheld the independent medical review system. The worker had CRPS in both feet and used a wheelchair. Utilization review denied her physician's request for four medications and a home health aide, and independent medical review upheld the denial. The Court of Appeal rejected her constitutional and due process arguments, holding that the Legislature has plenary power over workers' compensation. It also held that the Board had "misunderstood its statutory authority in one respect" and sent the home health aide request back. The page on treatment approval explains the review process.

Which of these decisions did the worker lose?

The worker lost in two of the ten, each in part. In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021), the Appeals Board denied permanent total disability, denied an alternative claim for a 93 percent rating, and left in place a finding that CRPS in the worker's arms and other leg was not caused by her job. She did obtain an increase from 78 to 87 percent. In Stevens (2015), the worker lost her constitutional challenge and won only a narrow remand. In the other eight decisions the worker's award or claim was upheld. In none of the ten did the Board or a court hold that CRPS is not a real condition.

Which binding decisions do the CRPS panels rely on?

The CRPS panels apply three en banc decisions of the Appeals Board that are not about CRPS. Almaraz/Guzman (2009) allows a physician to use any chapter, table or method in the AMA Guides that most accurately reflects the impairment. Vigil v. County of Kern (2024) states when impairments may be added instead of combined. Wilson v. State of CA Cal Fire (2019) sets the factors for deciding whether an injury is catastrophic, which controls whether a psychiatric rating can be added for injuries on or after January 1, 2013.

Common questions

Yes, as persuasive authority. The Appeals Board stated in Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (2024) that "panel decisions are citable authority and we may consider these decisions to the extent that we find their reasoning persuasive." They are not binding on other panels or on workers' compensation judges. Garibay (2024) shows the practice: the trial judge there relied on the 2021 panel decision in Scatena, calling it "almost exactly on point." The Board cautions that anyone citing a panel decision should verify its subsequent history.

The Appeals Board publishes its decisions on the California Department of Industrial Relations website. Its en banc decisions page links to separate lists of en banc decisions, significant panel decisions and panel decisions, each as a document. Every decision on this page links to the text that was read. Court of Appeal opinions are published by the California courts and in the official reports.

No. The decisions report permanent disability percentages from 62 to 100 percent, and each percentage came from one worker's medical evidence, age and occupation. This page leaves out dollar amounts. Workers' compensation benefits are set by statute and depend on the worker's earnings and date of injury, so the same percentage pays different workers different sums. The decisions here were located because they were contested and written up, so they are not a representative sample of CRPS claims.

The Appeals Board decides medical questions on the reports and testimony of evaluating physicians. In Pearson Ford (2017), the Court of Appeal quoted the rule that "workers' compensation law favors agreed medical examiners in resolving medical disputes fairly and expeditiously." In Barreto v. City of Vallejo (2026), the Board wrote that an agreed evaluator's opinion "should therefore be followed unless there is good cause to find it unpersuasive." The page on QME and AME examinations explains who these evaluators are.

It has rejected part of one. In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021), the Board accepted CRPS of the worker's left ankle but left in place the judge's finding that CRPS in her arms and other leg was not work-related. The pain medicine evaluator had found minimal CRPS in the left leg and attributed her other symptoms to non-industrial conditions. In Scatena, Garibay and Barreto, employers challenged the diagnosis and the Board upheld it each time.

Yes, three of them. In Hikida (2017), CRPS followed carpal tunnel surgery. In Garibay (2024), the evaluator attributed CRPS to the work injury "as well as surgery for industrial injury." In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021), the agreed evaluator testified that the CRPS resulted from the worker's industrial surgery and, relying on Hikida, assigned no apportionment. The page on CRPS after surgery covers the medical research.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (Feb. 9, 2021, ADJ12221781)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
  2. Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (Dec. 6, 2021, ADJ10902155)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
  3. Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (Feb. 20, 2024, ADJ9352174)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  4. Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International, Inc. (Mar. 15, 2024, ADJ15533334)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  5. Fanning v. Gelsons Market (Apr. 8, 2024, ADJ10862354)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  6. Barreto v. City of Vallejo (Mar. 12, 2026, ADJ13057169)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2026 · checked
  7. Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 1249Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District, 2017 · checked
  8. Pearson Ford v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Hernandez) (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 889Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, 2017 · checked
  9. Stevens v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 1074Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, First District, 2015 · checked
  10. Matea v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2006) 144 Cal.App.4th 1435Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Sixth District, 2006 · checked
  11. Almaraz v. Environmental Recovery Services / Guzman v. Milpitas Unified School Dist. (2009) 74 Cal.Comp.Cases 1084Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (en banc), 2009 · checked
  12. Wilson v. State of CA Cal Fire (2019) 84 Cal.Comp.Cases 393Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (en banc), 2019 · checked
  13. Vigil v. County of Kern (2024) 89 Cal.Comp.Cases 686Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (en banc), 2024 · checked
  14. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board en banc decisionsGovernment agency · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall