How is CRPS rated for permanent disability in California?

California rates permanent disability from complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) under Labor Code section 4660.1. An evaluating physician assigns a whole person impairment from the AMA Guides, 5th Edition. That figure is multiplied by 1.4 and adjusted for age and occupation. The scheduled rating is prima facie evidence, and a physician can rebut it with another method inside the Guides.

A painted hard hat and work gloves with wild grasses.

What law sets the permanent disability rating for CRPS in California?

Labor Code section 4660.1 sets the rating method for California work injuries on or after January 1, 2013, and it has no separate rule for complex regional pain syndrome. Section 4660.1 requires that "account shall be taken of the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement, the occupation of the injured employee, and the employee's age at the time of injury." The nature of the injury is measured with the "percentages of impairments published in the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition)," and the whole person impairment is "multiplied by an adjustment factor of 1.4." Labor Code section 4660 governs injuries before 2013.

How does a whole person impairment become a permanent disability percentage?

A whole person impairment becomes a permanent disability percentage in three steps described by the California Division of Workers' Compensation. An evaluating physician states the impairment as a percentage. For injuries on or after January 1, 2013, that percentage is multiplied by 1.4. The 2005 Permanent Disability Rating Schedule then adjusts the result for occupation and age. In Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (2021), a police officer's 45 percent whole person impairment for CRPS of the right arm produced "a final rating of 73 percent" after adjustment for age and occupation. Section 4660.1 makes the schedule "prima facie evidence of the percentage of permanent disability," which means the scheduled rating can be rebutted.

Which AMA Guides tables have evaluators used to rate CRPS of the arm?

Evaluators have rated CRPS of the arm under at least four tables of the AMA Guides, 5th Edition. This page did not open the Guides. The table reports what each Appeals Board panel decision says the physician did.

AMA Guides methods used to rate CRPS of the arm in four Appeals Board panel decisions
DecisionMethod the decision describesImpairment the evaluator found
Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (2021)"The CRPS portion of chapter 16"75 percent of the upper extremity, or 45 percent whole person
Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International (2024)Table 16-10a, grade 3, for sensory deficit and pain50 percent of the upper extremity for CRPS; 34 percent whole person with the thumb surgery
Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (2024)Table 16-4, by analogy to a shoulder disarticulation, preferred over Table 13-2260 percent whole person under Table 16-4; 39 percent under Table 13-22
Fanning v. Gelsons Market (2024)Table 13-16 for each arm, with the two figures added50 percent and 14 percent whole person, 64 percent in total

Which AMA Guides tables have evaluators used to rate CRPS of the leg?

Evaluators in two panel decisions rated CRPS of the leg with a table for station and gait in the chapter on the nervous system. In Barreto v. City of Vallejo (2026), the agreed medical evaluator cited page 553 of the Guides for the statement that "CRPS is currently believed to occur in the central nervous system," so that leg impairment is rated under Table 13-15.

AMA Guides methods used to rate CRPS of the leg in two Appeals Board panel decisions
DecisionMethod the decision describesImpairment the evaluator found
Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021)Table 13-15, station and gait, class 2 (pain medicine evaluator); Table 17-5, gait derangement (orthopedic evaluator)19 percent whole person under Table 13-15; 60 percent under Table 17-5
Barreto v. City of Vallejo (2026)Table 13-15, station and gait19 percent whole person, plus a 3 percent add-on for pain

Must a doctor find 8 of the 11 AMA Guides criteria before CRPS can be rated?

No, according to two Appeals Board panel decisions. In Scatena, the employer argued that the evaluator had not documented at least eight of the 11 "objective diagnostic criteria" in Table 16-16 of the AMA Guides. The judge's report, which the Board adopted, answered that "the diagnostic criteria set forth in the CRPS section of the AMA Guides are not a legal standard," and that the Guides "are not, however, a diagnostic tool." In Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International (2024), the employer made the same argument and asked for a 17 percent rating. The Board denied reconsideration, stating that "the AMA Guides are not used for the purpose of diagnosing an injury."

Can a workers' compensation evaluator diagnose CRPS with the Budapest criteria?

Yes. Appeals Board panels have accepted CRPS diagnoses made with the Budapest criteria. In Scatena, the treating physician applied the Budapest criteria and the judge found his findings consistent with the evaluator's. In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021), the pain medicine evaluator wrote that the worker "does not fit the criteria of complex regional pain syndrome per the AMA Guides but meets the Budapest criteria." The Board has not made either method exclusive. In Barreto v. City of Vallejo (2026), it upheld an evaluator who relied on history, examination findings and the AMA Guides, noting that the Budapest criteria do "not close the door on other avenues for diagnoses."

What is an Almaraz/Guzman rating, and how has it been used for CRPS?

An Almaraz/Guzman rating replaces the standard impairment figure with another figure from inside the AMA Guides that describes the worker more accurately. The Appeals Board's 2009 en banc decision held that "a physician may utilize any chapter, table, or method in the AMA Guides that most accurately reflects the injured employee's impairment," but may not go outside the Guides. The Court of Appeal affirmed in Milpitas Unified School Dist. v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808, and section 4660.1 states that the Legislature did not intend to overrule that holding.

In Meanor, the evaluator described the arm as "an essentially nonfunctional limb nearly equivalent to a shoulder disarticulation" and rated it as a lost arm. In Scatena, the evaluator testified that a rating of 9 percent based on loss of motion did not reflect the worker's impairment.

Can CRPS impairment be added to other impairments instead of combined?

Yes, when the medical evidence explains why. Separate impairments are ordinarily merged with the Combined Values Chart in the rating schedule, which yields less than their sum. In Vigil v. County of Kern (2024), the Appeals Board held en banc that impairments may be added when the worker shows the effect of each impairment on activities of daily living and either no overlap between those effects or an overlap that amplifies them. In Meanor, the Board upheld adding psychiatric and dental impairments to the CRPS rating, which produced 100 percent. In Barreto, it upheld adding leg, knee and back impairments on the agreed evaluator's testimony about a "synergistic effect," for a 62 percent rating.

Is pain rated separately in a CRPS permanent disability rating?

The decisions show evaluators treating pain in two ways. In Barreto, the agreed medical evaluator assigned 19 percent whole person impairment for CRPS of the leg and included a "3% pain add-on" to account for pain-related depression, sexual dysfunction and difficulties with positioning. In Wilson, the orthopedic evaluator did not add three percent for pain, because the pain was what caused the worker's use of a wheelchair. In Garibay, the evaluator graded pain itself under Table 16-10a, by how much it interfered with daily activities. Each approach was accepted on the medical explanation given for it.

Can the employer reduce a CRPS rating through apportionment in California?

Sometimes. Labor Code section 4663 states that "apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation," and section 4664 makes the employer liable only for "the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the injury." Two limits appear in the CRPS decisions. In Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 1249, the Court of Appeal held that disability caused by medical treatment of a work injury, there CRPS after carpal tunnel surgery, is compensated "without apportionment." In Fanning v. Gelsons Market (2024), the Board rejected a 25 percent apportionment to an earlier CRPS episode because the physician did not explain "how and why" the earlier condition was causing disability.

What does the final permanent disability percentage decide?

The final percentage decides how many weeks of permanent disability payments are owed and whether payments continue for life. Labor Code section 4658 assigns a number of weeks for each percentage point, rising from 3 weeks per point below 10 percent to 16 weeks per point from 70 to 99.75 percent. The Division of Workers' Compensation lists the weekly permanent partial disability rate for 2026 injuries at $160 to $290. Under Labor Code section 4659, a rating of 70 to 99.75 percent adds a life pension, and a rating of 100 percent is permanent total disability, paid for life.

Common questions

No. The Appeals Board explained in Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (2024) that "panel decisions are not binding precedent on other Appeals Board panels" or on workers' compensation judges, although they are citable and may be considered for their reasoning. En banc decisions of the Board, such as Almaraz/Guzman (2009) and Vigil v. County of Kern (2024), are binding on all panels and judges. Published Court of Appeal opinions such as Hikida and Guzman bind the Board. The CRPS panel decisions on this page show how the rules have been applied, not how a later case must be decided.

It did in the decisions on this page. In Meanor, an orthopedic evaluator rated the worker's arm at 39 percent whole person impairment and a physical medicine and pain management evaluator rated the same arm at 60 percent; the judge found the second opinion more persuasive. In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store, the orthopedic agreed medical evaluator wrote that he had no training in pain management and deferred the cause of CRPS to a pain medicine evaluator. The page on QME and AME examinations explains how evaluators are chosen.

The Appeals Board has upheld a CRPS rating made without one. In Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (2021), the qualified medical evaluator testified that three of the 11 criteria in the AMA Guides would have required a bone scan or X-ray and that he did not find it necessary to order X-rays, bone scans or nerve tests. The judge found his explanation "thorough and persuasive," and the Board denied the employer's petition. Medical guidelines likewise treat CRPS as a clinical diagnosis, as the page on how CRPS is diagnosed explains.

Permanent disability is rated once the condition is permanent and stationary. The Division of Workers' Compensation describes that point as the time when the doctor decides the injury "has stabilized and no change is likely," also called maximal medical improvement. In Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International, the qualified medical evaluator first reported in July 2022 that the worker with CRPS was not yet permanent and stationary, then re-evaluated her in October 2022 and rated her impairment. Until that point the worker may be receiving temporary disability.

For injuries on or after January 1, 2013, usually not. Labor Code section 4660.1 provides that impairment ratings for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction or psychiatric disorder "arising out of a compensable physical injury shall not increase," with exceptions for psychiatric injury that results from a violent act or a catastrophic injury. Treatment for those conditions remains available. The rule and its exceptions are covered on the page about psychiatric and sleep claims.

Labor Code section 5410 lets an injured worker seek more compensation "within five years after the date of the injury upon the ground that the original injury has caused new and further disability." The new disability still has to be shown to come from the work injury. In Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (2021), the judge found that claimed CRPS in the worker's arms and other leg was not caused by the work injury. The pain medicine evaluator had attributed those symptoms to conditions unrelated to work. The Board deferred a separate petition alleging new and further disability.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Labor Code section 4660.1Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  2. Labor Code section 4660Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  3. Labor Code section 4658Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  4. Labor Code section 4659Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  5. Labor Code section 4663Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  6. Labor Code section 4664Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  7. Labor Code section 5410Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  8. Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (Feb. 9, 2021, ADJ12221781)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
  9. Wilson v. Kohls Department Store (Dec. 6, 2021, ADJ10902155)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
  10. Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International, Inc. (Mar. 15, 2024, ADJ15533334)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  11. Meanor v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (Feb. 20, 2024, ADJ9352174)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  12. Fanning v. Gelsons Market (Apr. 8, 2024, ADJ10862354)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
  13. Barreto v. City of Vallejo (Mar. 12, 2026, ADJ13057169)Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2026 · checked
  14. Almaraz v. Environmental Recovery Services / Guzman v. Milpitas Unified School Dist. (2009) 74 Cal.Comp.Cases 1084Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (en banc), 2009 · checked
  15. Vigil v. County of Kern (2024) 89 Cal.Comp.Cases 686Court opinion · California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (en banc), 2024 · checked
  16. Milpitas Unified School Dist. v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Sixth District, 2010 · checked
  17. Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 1249Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District, 2017 · checked
  18. Permanent disability benefitsGovernment agency · California Division of Workers' Compensation · checked
  19. Workers' compensation benefits (rate charts and the 1.4 whole person impairment modifier)Government agency · California Division of Workers' Compensation · checked
  20. Answers to frequently asked questions about workers' compensation for employeesGovernment agency · California Division of Workers' Compensation · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall