What happens at a QME exam for CRPS?
At a qualified medical evaluator (QME) exam, a state-certified physician examines the injured worker, reviews the records and writes a medical-legal report. In a California CRPS claim, the report addresses disputed questions such as whether work caused the condition and how it is rated. An agreed medical evaluator (AME) does the same job by agreement of both sides.

What is a QME, and what is an AME?
A qualified medical evaluator, or QME, is a physician certified by the Division of Workers' Compensation Medical Unit "to examine injured workers to evaluate disability and write medical-legal reports." The division states that the reports "are used to determine an injured worker's eligibility for workers' compensation benefits." A QME is drawn from a randomly generated list of three, called a panel.
An agreed medical evaluator, or AME, is a physician chosen by agreement between the worker's attorney and the claims administrator. The division's Fact Sheet E states that AMEs "are only used if the injured worker is represented by an attorney." Labor Code section 4062.1 bars an employer from seeking agreement on an AME with a worker who has no attorney.
Why would a CRPS claim go to a QME or AME?
A CRPS claim goes to a medical-legal evaluator when the worker or the claims administrator disagrees with the treating physician on a medical question. The Division of Workers' Compensation lists the usual disputes: whether work caused the injury, whether the worker needs time off to recover, whether the condition is permanent and stationary, whether there is new and further disability, and the permanent disability rating.
Three statutes sort the disputes. Labor Code section 4060 covers whether the injury is compensable, section 4061 covers permanent impairment and the need for future medical care, and section 4062 covers other medical issues. In the CRPS decisions discussed on this page, the dispute was the diagnosis itself and the rating that followed from it.
Can a QME overturn a denial of CRPS treatment?
No. Treatment denials are outside the QME process. Labor Code section 4062(b) states that an employee's objection to a utilization review decision "shall be resolved only in accordance with the independent medical review process." Fact Sheet E states that an evaluator addresses the need for treatment "only if date of injury is before Jan. 1, 2013." A QME can still address the need for future medical care when rating a permanent condition under section 4061. Why CRPS treatment is denied and how to appeal covers the treatment appeal.
How is the evaluator chosen in a California workers' compensation claim?
The method depends on whether the worker has an attorney. Either way, the Medical Unit issues a random panel of three QMEs in the specialty named on the request form. The table compares the two panel procedures with an AME.
| Situation | Who picks the evaluator | Time limit |
|---|---|---|
| Worker without an attorney, panel QME | The worker selects one physician from the panel of three and schedules the exam | 10 days after the panel issues, then the employer may select |
| Worker with an attorney, panel QME | Each side may strike one name, and the remaining physician is the evaluator | 10 days after the panel is assigned to strike a name |
| Worker with an attorney, AME | The attorney and the claims administrator agree on one physician | At any time, by agreement |
Why does the QME's specialty matter in a CRPS claim?
The specialty decides what kind of physician evaluates the CRPS, and one side picks it. Fact Sheet E states, "Whoever submits the request form picks the specialty of the doctor for the exam." An unrepresented worker who receives the panel request form has 10 days to submit it, and after that the claims administrator may submit the form and choose the specialty.
Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (2021), a Workers' Compensation Appeals Board panel decision, shows how much the evaluator's method can change the result. The QME, a physical medicine and rehabilitation physician who had treated "hundreds" of patients with CRPS, rated the worker's arm at 45 percent whole person impairment as CRPS. Asked to consider loss of motion alone, he calculated 9 percent.
What does the evaluator look for when examining for CRPS?
An evaluator examining for CRPS looks for the findings the diagnostic criteria require and for other explanations. The Budapest criteria require signs observed at the examination in at least two of four categories. The 2022 practical guidelines in Pain Medicine state that a sign "is counted only if it is observed at time of diagnosis." CRPS signs fluctuate, so one appointment can miss them.
The worker's own account is part of the evidence. In Scatena, the QME observed some signs and documented others from the worker's report. The worker testified that his arm was more sensitive, changed color, was cooler than the other arm and sweated more. The judge found the testimony "credible and unrebutted."
Does the AMA Guides test of eight signs out of eleven control the CRPS diagnosis?
No, according to several Appeals Board panel decisions. The AMA Guides, fifth edition, list eleven objective criteria for CRPS and call for eight. Insurers commonly argue that fewer than eight means no ratable CRPS. In Scatena, the judge's adopted report stated that the AMA Guides "are not, however, a diagnostic tool."
In Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International (2024), a panel reasoned that the AMA Guides "are not used for the purpose of diagnosing an injury." In Wilson v. Kohl's Department Store (2021), the evaluator wrote that the worker "does not fit the criteria of complex regional pain syndrome per the AMA Guides but meets the Budapest criteria." Panel decisions are not binding precedent.
What records and information can be sent to the QME?
Either side may send the QME the treating physicians' records and other medical and nonmedical records relevant to the medical issue, under Labor Code section 4062.3. Anything a party proposes to send must be served on the other side 20 days before it goes to the evaluator. If the other side objects to nonmedical records within 10 days, those records are not provided.
Private contact with the evaluator is prohibited. Section 4062.3 requires communications with a panel QME to be in writing and served on the opposing party, and it states, "Ex parte communication with an agreed medical evaluator or a qualified medical evaluator selected from a panel is prohibited." The rule does not apply to what the worker says in the course of the examination. The report must list everything the evaluator received, reviewed and relied on.
What rights does a worker have at the QME appointment?
An unrepresented worker has the right to ask questions first. Labor Code section 4062.1(d) requires the evaluator to give the employee "a brief opportunity to ask questions concerning the evaluation process and the evaluator's background." The worker may stop the evaluation for good cause, which includes evidence of bias or a request for "an unnecessary medical examination or procedure," and then receives a new panel. If the Appeals Board later finds there was no good cause, the cost of the evaluation is deducted from the worker's award.
The panel notice must tell the worker that he or she "is entitled to receive transportation expenses and temporary disability for each day necessary for the examination," under Labor Code section 139.2(h). A represented worker "shall not unreasonably refuse to participate in the evaluation," under section 4062.2(d).
How long does the QME report take, and what happens next?
The initial report is due within 30 days. Labor Code section 139.2(j) sets the timeframe at "no more than 30 days after the evaluator has seen the employee," with extensions when test results or a consultation are pending, or up to 15 days for good cause. The evaluator serves the report on the worker and the employer.
For a worker without an attorney, the report also goes to the state, which calculates a permanent disability rating within 20 days under Labor Code section 4061(e). Within 30 days after receiving the report, the unrepresented worker or the employer may each request one supplemental report "seeking correction of factual errors."
Is the QME's opinion on CRPS the final word?
No. A workers' compensation judge decides the case and weighs the evaluator's report with the other evidence. In Scatena, both sides questioned the QME at a deposition, and the judge found that he gave "a thorough and persuasive explanation" of the CRPS diagnosis. The panel notice required by Labor Code section 139.2 tells workers that the judge "will consider the evaluation prepared by the doctor you select to decide your claim."
The same evaluator usually stays on the case. Section 4062.3(k) directs the parties, "to the extent possible," to use the same evaluator for later disputes. A worker evaluated without an attorney is not entitled to an additional evaluation after hiring one, under section 4062.1(e).
Common questions
Sources
Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.
- Fact Sheet E: Answers to Your Questions About Qualified Medical Evaluators and Agreed Medical EvaluatorsGovernment agency · California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation, 2024 · checked
- Qualified medical evaluator (QME) processGovernment agency · California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation · checked
- Qualified medical evaluator database searchGovernment agency · California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation · checked
- Labor Code section 139.2Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4060Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4061Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4062Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4062.1Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4062.2Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Labor Code section 4062.3Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
- Scatena v. Tower of Hillsborough (February 9, 2021) ADJ12221781, opinion and order denying petition for reconsiderationCourt opinion · Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
- Garibay v. Scientific Drilling International, Inc. (March 15, 2024) ADJ15533334, opinion and order denying petition for reconsiderationCourt opinion · Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2024 · checked
- Wilson v. Kohl's Department Store (December 6, 2021) ADJ10902155Court opinion · Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (panel decision), 2021 · checked
- Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (Hernandez) (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 889Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, 2017 · checked
- Validation of proposed diagnostic criteria (the "Budapest Criteria") for Complex Regional Pain SyndromeStudy · Pain (Harden et al.), 2010 · checked
- Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: Practical Diagnostic and Treatment Guidelines, 5th EditionClinical guideline · Pain Medicine (Harden et al.), 2022 · checked

Workers' compensation and CRPS
How CRPS is diagnosed
The defense medical exam
Budapest criteria self-check
CRPS symptom diary