How do insurers fight CRPS claims?

Insurers commonly dispute complex regional pain syndrome claims in California by arguing that the diagnosis is wrong, the pain is psychological, the injury was too minor, an earlier condition is the real cause, or the person will recover. California jury instructions CACI Nos. 430, 431, 3927, 3928 and 3929 answer most of these arguments when the medical proof is sound.

Painted scales of justice holding a poppy and lupine.

Which arguments do insurers commonly raise against CRPS claims in California?

Insurers commonly raise the same group of arguments against complex regional pain syndrome claims, because the condition has no confirming test and its signs change from day to day. Each argument has a response in California law or in the medical record.

Common insurer arguments in California CRPS claims and what answers each
Insurer argumentWhat answers the argument in a California CRPS claim
The Budapest criteria are not metSigns recorded by several treating doctors on several dates
The pain is psychologicalCACI Nos. 3927 and 3928; recorded physical signs
The impact was too minorCACI No. 3928; medical evidence that severity of trauma does not predict CRPS
An earlier condition is the causeCACI Nos. 431 and 3927
Video shows normal activityThe full footage and objective findings, as in Pearson Ford (2017)
Gaps in treatment show little painCACI No. 3930 and the reasons for each gap
The treating doctors caused itCACI No. 3929
The person will recoverCACI No. 3903A and the recovery studies

How do insurers argue that the condition is not CRPS?

Insurers commonly rely on a physician who examines the person once and reports that the Budapest criteria were not met. In Yoder v. Okhovat, an unpublished 2023 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, the defense's medical expert called CRPS "a diagnosis of exclusion" under "the very stringent Budapest Criteria." In Abbott v. Taz Express, a published 1998 opinion of the Fourth District, the defense attacked "the highly questionable nature of [her] medical condition."

The response is the record over time. Social Security Ruling 03-2p states that signs "may be present at one examination and not appear at another" and that "Transient findings are characteristic of RSDS/CRPS." The defense medical exam guide explains the rules for that examination.

How do insurers argue that CRPS pain is psychological?

Insurers commonly retain a psychiatrist or psychologist to say the pain comes from a psychological condition. In Yoder v. Okhovat, the unpublished 2023 opinion, the defense said the plaintiff's symptoms "demonstrably have a psychogenic component." A 2008 Dutch study of 186 patients and 697 controls by de Mos and colleagues reported, "Psychological factors were not associated with CRPS onset."

California law answers the argument in two instructions. CACI No. 3928 requires full compensation for a plaintiff who "was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person would have been." CACI No. 3927 requires compensation when a prior "physical or emotional condition" was "made worse" by the defendant's conduct.

What do insurers do with surveillance video in a CRPS claim?

Insurers commonly hire investigators to film a person and then argue that the video contradicts the reported limits. In Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, a published 2017 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, an investigator filmed a worker with a crushed finger and a regional pain syndrome diagnosis after three medical visits. The worker later pleaded to misdemeanor workers' compensation fraud.

The agreed medical examiner watched the videos and said, "I do not recall seeing any individual finger motion in the videos." The court upheld a 70 percent permanent disability award because it rested on evidence independent of the fraud. The surveillance guide covers the case in detail.

How do insurers argue that a minor impact cannot cause CRPS?

Insurers commonly present an engineer who testifies that the forces in a collision or fall were too small to cause injury. Social Security Ruling 03-2p states that "Even a minor injury can trigger RSDS/CRPS," and the Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline states, "There is no relationship to the severity of trauma."

A California judge screens the engineer's testimony under Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California, a published 2012 opinion of the Supreme Court of California, which directs trial courts to exclude speculative expert opinion testimony. The guide on small injuries and large harm explains CACI No. 3928.

What if the insurer blames a pre-existing condition for the CRPS?

Insurers commonly search years of medical records for earlier complaints in the same limb or for earlier anxiety or depression. Under CACI No. 3927, a plaintiff "is not entitled to damages for any physical or emotional condition" that existed before the defendant's conduct, but is compensated if the conduct made the condition worse.

CACI No. 431 covers combined causes of complex regional pain syndrome. It states that a defendant "cannot avoid responsibility just because some other person, condition, or event was also a substantial factor in causing" the plaintiff's harm. The plaintiff's medical expert must address each earlier record specifically. In Fernandez v. Alexander, a published 2019 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, a causation opinion that did not explain its reasoning failed.

Can an insurer use gaps in treatment against a CRPS claim?

Insurers commonly argue that a person in severe pain would not have gone months without treatment. California's instruction on avoidable harm, CACI No. 3930, says a plaintiff is not entitled to recover damages for harm that the defendant proves the plaintiff "could have avoided with reasonable efforts or expenditures."

CACI No. 3930 measures reasonableness "in light of the circumstances," including the plaintiff's "ability to make the efforts or expenditures without undue risk or hardship." A gap in CRPS treatment that followed an insurance denial, a lost job or a delayed authorization is explained by records of those events. The burden of proving avoidable harm is on the defendant.

How do insurers argue that a person with CRPS will get better?

Insurers commonly argue that complex regional pain syndrome resolves, so future care and future pain should be valued low. The studies differ. In a population study in Olmsted County, Minnesota, Sandroni and colleagues reported in 2003 that 74 percent of 74 cases resolved. In a 2016 New Zealand study by Bean and colleagues of 59 patients followed for one year, "Only 5.4% of patients were symptom-free."

California's standard is CACI No. 3903A, which allows future medical expenses for care the plaintiff "is reasonably certain to need in the future." The treating doctors' prognosis, the length of the symptoms so far and the treatments that have failed are the evidence on that point.

Can the defense blame the treating doctors for the CRPS?

A defendant may claim that medical treatment caused or worsened the condition. CACI No. 3929 makes the original wrongdoer "also responsible for any additional harm resulting from the acts of others in providing medical treatment or other aid" that the injury reasonably required, "even if those acts were negligently performed."

The defense still appears because California's Civil Code section 1431.2 makes each defendant's liability for noneconomic damages "several only" and in proportion to fault. In Allphin v. Peter K. Fitness, LLC, a 2015 decision of the federal district court for the Northern District of California published in the Federal Supplement, the defendants pleaded that treating doctors' malpractice should absorb part of the damages for the plaintiff's CRPS. The court granted the plaintiff partial summary judgment on that defense.

How does comparative fault reduce a CRPS recovery in California?

Insurers commonly argue that the injured person was partly at fault for the event. California uses pure comparative fault. In Li v. Yellow Cab Co., a published 1975 opinion, the Supreme Court of California adopted a system under which liability is borne "in direct proportion to their respective fault." A person found partly at fault still recovers, with the damages reduced by that share.

Abbott v. Taz Express shows the effect. The jury's award to a woman diagnosed with reflex sympathetic dystrophy, the former name for CRPS type I, was reduced for her share of fault before judgment was entered.

Which defenses have defeated CRPS claims in California appellate opinions?

In the California appellate opinions reviewed for this site, the people with complex regional pain syndrome who lost did so on causation proof or on liability. Fernandez v. Alexander (2019, published) and Yoder v. Okhovat (2023, unpublished) ended in summary judgment because the medical evidence on causation was inadequate.

Smith v. Magic Mountain LLC, a partially published 2024 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, affirmed a defense verdict after a jury found no negligence in a hand injury in a ride queue. None of the three opinions rests on a finding that CRPS is not a real condition.

Common questions

Complex regional pain syndrome has no confirming laboratory test or scan, its signs fluctuate, and its pain is by definition out of proportion to the original injury. Those features give an insurer room to question the diagnosis. Future care can also continue for many years, which raises the amount in dispute. The answer in a California claim is documentation: examination findings recorded on many dates, photographs, measurements and medical expert testimony.

In a California lawsuit for personal injuries, Code of Civil Procedure section 2032.220 allows a defendant to demand one physical examination of the plaintiff. The examination may not include any diagnostic test or procedure that is painful, protracted, or intrusive and must take place within 75 miles of the examinee's residence. The plaintiff's attorney may attend and make an audio recording under section 2032.510. A second examination requires a court order.

A prior emotional condition does not bar a California claim. CACI No. 3927 says a plaintiff is not compensated for a condition that existed before the defendant's conduct but is compensated for the effect of that conduct in making it worse. CACI No. 3928 requires full compensation even if the plaintiff was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person. A 2008 study by de Mos and colleagues found psychological factors were not associated with the onset of CRPS.

No. The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline states that CRPS is a clinical diagnosis that does not depend on the results of a bone scan. A 2017 meta-analysis by Wertli and colleagues found bone scans had a sensitivity of 0.55 measured against the Budapest criteria. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke states that nerve conduction tests usually cannot confirm CRPS type 1. A normal test is one piece of evidence beside the examination records.

Insurers commonly raise symptom exaggeration in complex regional pain syndrome claims, often through an examining doctor's comments or surveillance video. Allodynia, which is pain from a stimulus that does not normally hurt, is a recognized sign in the Budapest criteria, so a strong reaction to light touch is part of the condition. Consistent, accurate reports to every doctor matter. In Pearson Ford (2017), objective medical findings supported an award even after surveillance.

No outcome can be predicted from a list of arguments. Each defense described here has an answer in California's jury instructions or in the evidence, and each has also succeeded in a case where the medical proof was thin. The California opinions reviewed for this site show claims failing on causation proof or liability. A California injury lawyer can review the records and say which defenses are likely in a particular case.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 editionJury instruction · Judicial Council of California, 2026 · checked
  2. Social Security Ruling 03-2p: Evaluating Cases Involving Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome/Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, 68 Fed. Reg. 59971Government agency · Social Security Administration (Federal Register), 2003 · checked
  3. Complex regional pain syndrome in adults: UK guidelines for diagnosis, referral and management in primary and secondary care, 2nd editionClinical guideline · Royal College of Physicians, 2018 · checked
  4. Yoder v. Okhovat (Aug. 24, 2023, B320945)Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District, Division One (unpublished), 2023 · checked
  5. Abbott v. Taz Express (1998) 67 Cal.App.4th 853Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three (published), 1998 · checked
  6. Pearson Ford v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Hernandez) (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 889Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One (published), 2017 · checked
  7. Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747Court opinion · Supreme Court of California (published), 2012 · checked
  8. Fernandez v. Alexander (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 770Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District (published), 2019 · checked
  9. Smith v. Magic Mountain LLC (Nov. 21, 2024, B330833)Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Two (partially published), 2024 · checked
  10. Allphin v. Peter K. Fitness, LLC (N.D. Cal. 2015) 78 F.Supp.3d 987Court opinion · United States District Court, Northern District of California (published in the Federal Supplement), 2015 · checked
  11. Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804Court opinion · Supreme Court of California (published), 1975 · checked
  12. Civil Code section 1431.2Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  13. Medical history and the onset of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS)Study · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2008 · checked
  14. Complex regional pain syndrome type I: incidence and prevalence in Olmsted County, a population-based studyStudy · Pain (Sandroni et al.), 2003 · checked
  15. Extent of recovery in the first 12 months of complex regional pain syndrome type-1: A prospective studyStudy · European Journal of Pain (Bean et al.), 2016 · checked
  16. Usefulness of bone scintigraphy for the diagnosis of Complex Regional Pain Syndrome 1: A systematic review and Bayesian meta-analysisStudy · PLoS One (Wertli et al.), 2017 · checked
  17. Complex Regional Pain SyndromeGovernment agency · National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke · checked
  18. Validation of proposed diagnostic criteria (the "Budapest Criteria") for Complex Regional Pain SyndromeStudy · Pain (Harden et al.), 2010 · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall