Can the insurance company follow me or read my social media?

Insurers do hire investigators to film people with complex regional pain syndrome claims, as the published California opinion Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (2017) shows. Civil Code section 1708.8 limits intrusion into private activity. Social media posts relevant to the injury can be requested in a lawsuit under Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010.

Painted scales of justice holding a poppy and lupine.

Do insurers really film people who have CRPS claims?

Yes. Insurers commonly hire investigators to film people who claim serious injuries, including complex regional pain syndrome. A California example is Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, a published 2017 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One.

In Pearson Ford, a worker crushed a finger in a car trunk, and his diagnoses included regional pain syndrome. He wore a sling to appointments and reported that he could not use the hand. The workers' compensation carrier's investigator filmed him after three medical visits taking off the sling, steering his truck with that hand and carrying a bag of groceries.

What did the Pearson Ford court decide about surveillance video?

The Pearson Ford court held that surveillance and a fraud conviction did not cancel benefits that were proved by independent medical evidence. After the video, the worker pleaded to misdemeanor workers' compensation fraud under Insurance Code section 1871.4 and paid $9,000 in restitution. The employer argued that Insurance Code section 1871.5 therefore barred any award for the injury.

The agreed medical examiner reviewed the videos, was deposed three times, and still found permanent disability based on objective findings. He wrote of the footage, "I do not recall seeing any individual finger motion in the videos but this was difficult to confirm." The Court of Appeal let the 70 percent permanent disability award stand.

What does Pearson Ford teach about statements to doctors?

Pearson Ford shows that the risk in surveillance is the gap between what a person told a doctor and what a camera shows. The opinion states that the worker misrepresented the extent of his injuries to two doctors and that those misrepresentations led to his conviction. He kept his award because other medical evidence, independent of the fraud, supported it.

Complex regional pain syndrome varies from day to day, and an accurate description of that variation protects a claim. A person who tells every doctor what the limb can do on a good day and what it cannot do on a bad day has given an account that a video of a good day does not contradict. A lawyer can explain how this applies in a particular case.

Where does California law limit an investigator?

California's Civil Code section 1708.8 limits how an investigator may record a person in private. Subdivision (a) creates liability for a person who "knowingly enters onto the land or into the airspace above the land of another person without permission" to capture an image or recording of someone engaged in a "private, personal, or familial activity," in a manner "offensive to a reasonable person."

Subdivision (b) reaches recording without a trespass. It applies when a device is used to capture an image that "could not have been achieved without a trespass unless the device was used." The wording of Civil Code section 1708.8 addresses private activity. It does not address what a person does in open public view.

Which California laws apply to surveillance and social media in a CRPS claim?

Five California laws cover most of what an insurer does to watch a person with a complex regional pain syndrome claim. The table lists each one beside the conduct it governs.

What insurers look at in a California CRPS claim and the law that applies
What the insurer looks atThe California law that applies
Video of a person in publicShown to doctors and courts in Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (2017)
Recording of private activity by trespass or deviceCivil Code section 1708.8 creates liability
Social media posts relevant to the injuryCode of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 allows discovery of relevant matter that is not privileged
Posts or files deleted after a claim beginsEvidence Code section 413 lets the jury consider willful suppression of evidence
False statements to obtain workers' compensation benefitsInsurance Code section 1871.4, the statute charged in Pearson Ford

Why can a short video misrepresent CRPS?

A video shows minutes, and complex regional pain syndrome changes over hours and days. Social Security Ruling 03-2p, the federal ruling on the condition, states that signs "may be present at one examination and not appear at another" and that "Transient findings are characteristic of RSDS/CRPS." A person who carries groceries on Tuesday may be unable to wear a shoe on Wednesday.

Video also does not show pain, skin temperature or what an activity cost afterward. In Pearson Ford, the agreed medical examiner found the videos "not very helpful in making any diagnosis." Treating records, dated photographs and a factual diary from the same days supply the context a clip leaves out.

Can the insurance company read my social media in a California lawsuit?

Anything posted publicly can be read by anyone, including an insurer, and in a lawsuit the defense can ask for more. California's Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 allows a party to obtain discovery "regarding any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the subject matter" of the case. The section covers documents and electronically stored information.

Insurers commonly request posts, photographs and messages about activities, travel, work or health after an injury in complex regional pain syndrome cases. The plaintiff's lawyer may object that a request is too broad or invades privacy, and a judge decides the dispute. The guide to insurer defenses shows where this evidence fits.

Does a private account setting keep posts out of a California lawsuit?

A privacy setting is not what Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 asks about. The section turns on two questions: whether the matter is privileged and whether it is relevant to the subject matter of the case. A setting that hides a post from the public does not make the post privileged.

What the defense actually receives from a private account depends on the requests, the objections and the judge's rulings in that case. A photograph of a person with CRPS smiling at a wedding says little about the following three days, yet it may be shown to a jury if it is produced. People who saw the event can supply the context.

Is deleting posts after an injury a problem in California?

Deleting material that relates to a claim can damage the claim more than the material would have. California's Evidence Code section 413 allows the trier of fact, in deciding what inferences to draw against a party, to consider the party's "willful suppression of evidence." A jury told that a plaintiff erased posts may assume the posts were harmful.

Criminal law also applies in some situations. Penal Code section 135 makes it a misdemeanor to willfully destroy, erase or conceal a record, digital image or video recording, knowing it is about to be produced in evidence, with the intent to prevent its production. A lawyer can explain what must be preserved in a particular case.

Can I see surveillance video that was taken of me?

Discovery runs in both directions. Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 extends to the existence, nature, custody and location of documents, electronically stored information and tangible things held by any party. A plaintiff's lawyer can use California's discovery procedures to ask whether surveillance exists and to seek the footage and the investigator's records.

Complete footage matters in a complex regional pain syndrome case, because a few edited minutes can leave out what the full recording shows. When and how the defense must turn footage over is decided under the discovery rules and, if the sides disagree, by the judge.

Does surveillance happen in workers' compensation CRPS claims too?

Yes. Pearson Ford was a workers' compensation case, and the investigator worked for the compensation carrier. The decision also shows the stakes. Insurance Code section 1871.4, the statute the worker pleaded to, makes it a crime to make a "knowingly false or fraudulent material statement" to obtain compensation, and the employer used the conviction to seek an end to the award.

The Court of Appeal held that the conviction did not bar benefits established by evidence independent of the fraud. The published opinion is the clearest California authority on what surveillance can and cannot do to a claim involving regional pain syndrome.

Common questions

California's Civil Code section 1708.8 creates liability for entering another person's land or airspace without permission, or using a device, to capture a person engaged in a private, personal, or familial activity in a manner offensive to a reasonable person. The statute's wording addresses private activity and trespass. In Pearson Ford v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, a published 2017 opinion, video taken by a carrier's investigator after medical visits was reviewed by the doctors and the court. A lawyer can assess a specific incident.

This page cannot give individual advice, and a lawyer can. The law is that Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 allows discovery of any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the subject matter of a lawsuit, which commonly includes posts about activities and health. A cheerful photograph shows one moment and none of the cost afterward.

Deleting material after a claim has begun carries legal risk. Evidence Code section 413 lets a California jury consider a party's willful suppression of evidence when deciding what inferences to draw. Penal Code section 135 makes it a misdemeanor to destroy or conceal a record or digital image, knowing it is about to be produced in evidence, with intent to prevent its production. Ask a lawyer before removing anything connected to an injury claim.

Using the limb on video does not disprove complex regional pain syndrome. Social Security Ruling 03-2p states that transient findings are characteristic of the condition. In Pearson Ford, a published 2017 California Court of Appeal opinion, the agreed medical examiner watched the surveillance videos and still found permanent disability on objective findings. What matters is whether the video conflicts with what the person told doctors and said under oath.

In a California lawsuit, the test under Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 is whether the matter is privileged and whether it is relevant to the subject matter. Messages between a client and a lawyer are a different category from messages to friends. Whether particular private messages must be produced depends on the request, the objections raised, including privacy, and the judge's ruling. A lawyer can explain which communications are protected.

Step counts, location history and similar data are electronically stored information, and Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010 allows discovery of relevant, unprivileged matter in that form. Whether a court orders production in a given CRPS case depends on relevance, the breadth of the request and privacy objections. The same data can also support a claim by showing how activity dropped after the injury.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Pearson Ford v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Hernandez) (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 889Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One (published), 2017 · checked
  2. Social Security Ruling 03-2p: Evaluating Cases Involving Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome/Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, 68 Fed. Reg. 59971Government agency · Social Security Administration (Federal Register), 2003 · checked
  3. Civil Code section 1708.8Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  4. Code of Civil Procedure section 2017.010Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  5. Evidence Code section 413Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  6. Penal Code section 135Statute · California Legislative Information · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall