Does a pre-existing condition hurt a CRPS claim?

A pre-existing condition does not bar a California claim for complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS). Under CACI No. 3927, a defendant does not pay for a condition the person already had but does pay for making it worse. Under CACI No. 3928, a defendant pays for the full harm even if the person was more susceptible to injury.

Painted scales of justice holding a poppy and lupine.

Can I recover for CRPS in California if I had health problems before the injury?

Yes. California law does not require an injured person to have been in perfect health. Two jury instructions govern prior health in a claim for complex regional pain syndrome. CACI No. 3927 covers a condition the person already had, and CACI No. 3928 covers a person who was more easily injured than most. The Sources and Authority for CACI No. 3928 quote Rideau v. Los Angeles Transit Lines, a published 1954 California Court of Appeal decision: "The tortfeasor takes the person he injures as he finds him." A prior condition changes what has to be proved and how damages are measured. It does not end the claim.

What does CACI No. 3927 say about a condition I already had?

CACI No. 3927, titled "Aggravation of Preexisting Condition or Disability," has two sentences that pull in opposite directions. The first protects the defendant: the plaintiff "is not entitled to damages for any physical or emotional condition" that the plaintiff "had before" the defendant's "conduct occurred." The second protects the plaintiff: if the plaintiff "had a physical or emotional condition that was made worse by" the defendant's "wrongful conduct, you must award damages that will reasonably and fairly compensate" the plaintiff "for the effect on that condition." Under CACI No. 3927 the defendant pays for the difference between the person's health before the injury and after it.

What does CACI No. 3928 say about a person who is more easily injured?

CACI No. 3928, titled "Unusually Susceptible Plaintiff," requires full compensation for a person who was more vulnerable than average. The instruction reads: "You must decide the full amount of money that will reasonably and fairly compensate" the plaintiff "for all damages caused by the wrongful conduct of" the defendant, "even if" the plaintiff "was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person would have been, and even if a normally healthy person would not have suffered similar injury." CACI No. 3928 fits CRPS closely, because most people who break a wrist or sprain an ankle do not develop the condition.

Which California jury instructions apply to prior health in a CRPS case?

Four California jury instructions answer most questions about prior health in a CRPS case.

California jury instructions on prior health and other causes in a CRPS claim
Jury instructionSituation it coversWhat the jury is told
CACI No. 3927The person had a physical or emotional condition before the injuryNo damages for the condition as it was. Damages for making it worse.
CACI No. 3928The person was more susceptible to injury than a healthy personThe full amount, even if a normally healthy person would not have suffered similar injury.
CACI No. 431The defense names another person, condition or event as a causeA defendant whose negligence was a substantial factor cannot avoid responsibility because of it.
CACI No. 3929A cast, surgery or other treatment for the injury added harmThe defendant is also responsible for harm from treatment the injury reasonably required.

What is the difference between a susceptibility and a pre-existing condition in a CRPS claim?

A susceptibility is a higher chance of harm with no symptoms yet, and a pre-existing condition is one that was already producing symptoms. The distinction decides which instruction applies. A person with a risk factor for CRPS and a healthy limb before the injury falls under CACI No. 3928, and the defendant pays for the full harm. A person who already had chronic pain in the same limb falls at least partly under CACI No. 3927, and the defendant pays for the worsening. The medical witnesses in a CRPS case are asked to separate the two in plain terms, using the records from before and after the injury.

Which health conditions have studies linked to a higher risk of CRPS?

Several conditions have been associated with CRPS in published studies. In a 2008 study of 186 CRPS patients and 697 controls, de Mos and colleagues reported odds ratios of 2.43 for migraine and 2.44 for osteoporosis, and 3.0 for asthma in a sensitivity analysis. A 2009 study by the same group reported an adjusted odds ratio of 2.7 for use of ACE inhibitors, a class of blood pressure medicine. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke lists asthma, ACE inhibitors, menopause, osteoporosis, migraine and smoking. Each of these is a risk factor, not CRPS itself, so each falls under the susceptibility rule in CACI No. 3928.

Can the defense blame the CRPS on my other conditions instead of the injury?

The defense can argue it, and California law limits the argument. CACI No. 431 states: "A person's negligence may combine with another factor to cause harm." If the defendant's negligence was a substantial factor in causing the harm, the defendant "cannot avoid responsibility just because some other person, condition, or event was also a substantial factor." Insurers commonly argue that genetics, smoking or an earlier illness was the real cause of the CRPS. Under CACI No. 431 those factors are, at most, additional causes. The defense argument succeeds only if the jury finds the injury was not a substantial factor at all, which is the subject of the page on proving causation.

Does a history of anxiety or depression defeat a CRPS claim?

No. A history of anxiety or depression does not show that CRPS is psychological, and the research does not support that inference. In the 2008 study by de Mos and colleagues, the authors reported: "Psychological factors were not associated with CRPS onset." A 2022 study by Bruehl and colleagues of 110 knee replacement patients concluded: "Preoperative negative affect is unlikely to directly influence long-term CRPS risk." On damages, CACI No. 3927 applies to an "emotional condition" the same way it applies to a physical one. The defendant does not pay for depression that existed before the injury and does pay for making it worse. The page on whether CRPS is psychological reviews the studies.

What if I had chronic pain or an earlier CRPS episode in the same limb?

Prior pain in the same limb is the situation in which a pre-existing condition matters most. The first sentence of CACI No. 3927 means the defendant does not pay for the pain, treatment or work limits that already existed. The second sentence means the defendant pays for the change. Proof of the change comes from comparing the two periods: what treatment the person needed, what work and activity the person managed, and what examiners recorded before and after the injury. Insurers commonly argue that all later symptoms continue the old condition. The medical records made before the injury are the evidence of what the earlier condition was.

Is the pre-existing condition rule different in California workers' compensation?

Yes. California workers' compensation divides permanent disability by cause in a way a civil lawsuit does not. Labor Code section 4663 states: "Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation." Labor Code section 4664 limits the employer to "the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment." There is a limit that matters for CRPS. In Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 1249, a published decision of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, an employee developed CRPS after surgery for a work-related condition. The court held the resulting disability must be compensated "without apportionment."

Common questions

Yes, if the defendant is responsible for the original injury. CACI No. 3929 states that the defendant "is also responsible for any additional harm resulting from the acts of others in providing medical treatment or other aid" that the injury "reasonably required, even if those acts were negligently performed." A defendant cannot treat the cast, the surgery or the period of immobilization as a separate cause that belongs to someone else when the injury made that treatment necessary.

Not under the susceptibility rule. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke lists smoking and ACE inhibitors among the factors associated with CRPS, and a 2009 study by de Mos and colleagues reported an adjusted odds ratio of 2.7 for ACE inhibitor use. A risk factor makes a person more susceptible. CACI No. 3928 requires full compensation "even if a normally healthy person would not have suffered similar injury."

Both instructions can apply to the same case. CACI No. 3927 directs the jury to compensate the effect of the defendant's conduct on the condition that was made worse. CACI No. 3928 covers the person's greater susceptibility to further harm. CRPS that develops after the aggravation is new harm, and the question is whether the defendant's conduct was a substantial factor in causing it under CACI No. 430.

A prior claim is evidence of what the person's condition was before the new injury. Under CACI No. 3927 that earlier condition is the baseline, and the defendant is responsible for the worsening. In California workers' compensation the effect is more direct, because Labor Code section 4664 limits the employer to the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the work injury.

No. Age and sex are characteristics, not pre-existing conditions. A 2007 population study in the Netherlands by de Mos and colleagues found the highest incidence of CRPS in women aged 61 to 70 and concluded that postmenopausal women appeared to be at the highest risk. Under CACI No. 3928, a defendant is responsible for the full harm to a person who was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person would have been.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 editionJury instruction · Judicial Council of California, 2026 · checked
  2. Medical history and the onset of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS)Study · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2008 · checked
  3. The association between ACE inhibitors and the complex regional pain syndrome: Suggestions for a neuro-inflammatory pathogenesis of CRPSStudy · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2009 · checked
  4. The incidence of complex regional pain syndrome: a population-based studyStudy · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2007 · checked
  5. Preoperative Predictors of Complex Regional Pain Syndrome Outcomes in the 6 Months Following Total Knee ArthroplastyStudy · The Journal of Pain (Bruehl et al.), 2022 · checked
  6. Complex Regional Pain SyndromeGovernment agency · National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke · checked
  7. Labor Code section 4663Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  8. Labor Code section 4664Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  9. Hikida v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 1249Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District (published), 2017 · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall