How do mirror therapy and graded motor imagery work?

Mirror therapy shows a person with complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) the reflection of the healthy limb moving in place of the painful one. Graded motor imagery builds up to the mirror in three steps: judging left and right limbs in pictures, imagining movements, then mirror practice. Small trials reported less pain, and guidelines say the benefit remains unproven.

A painted apothecary bottle and mortar with a poppy and lupine.

What is mirror therapy for CRPS?

Mirror therapy for complex regional pain syndrome uses a mirror placed between the limbs so that the reflection of the unaffected limb appears where the painful limb would be. The person moves the unaffected limb and watches the reflection, which looks like the affected limb moving without pain. Researchers call the method mirror visual feedback.

The 2022 practical guidelines in Pain Medicine trace mirror therapy to Ramachandran, who first used mirrors for phantom limb pain after amputation. McCabe and colleagues then tested mirror visual feedback in people with CRPS in 2003.

What is graded motor imagery?

Graded motor imagery is a three-step program that ends with mirror therapy and was designed by Moseley for long-standing CRPS. In the first step the person looks at pictures of hands or feet and judges whether each shows a left or a right limb. In the second step the person looks at a picture of a limb and imagines moving into that position. The third step is mirror therapy.

Moseley's graded motor imagery program for CRPS runs six weeks, with two weeks spent in each step, according to the 2022 practical guidelines. The steps are ordered so that the brain areas that plan movement are used before the limb itself moves.

Why would a mirror or imagined movement change CRPS pain?

The leading explanation is that CRPS involves changes in how the brain represents the limb, and that these therapies retrain it. McCabe's 2003 study tested the hypothesis that a mismatch between the movement the brain orders and the sensation that comes back produces CRPS pain. Seeing a limb move normally in the mirror is thought to correct the mismatch.

The mechanism is not settled. The 2022 practical guidelines state that the mechanisms behind any benefit of mirror therapy and graded motor imagery "are still somewhat unclear." The guidelines list focused attention on the affected limb, reduced fear of movement, and the reconciling of movement with sensation as possible contributors. Moseley's 2006 trial report says the mechanisms of the effect "are not clear."

What did the mirror therapy study in CRPS find?

McCabe's 2003 controlled pilot study found that mirror therapy helped early CRPS and did not help chronic CRPS. Eight people who had CRPS type I for between three weeks and three years were studied over six weeks. Two control stages, one with no device and one with a non-reflective surface, produced no pain relief.

With the mirror, people who had CRPS for eight weeks or less had immediate pain relief, and people with CRPS of up to one year had less stiffness. The authors reported, "No change was found in chronic CRPS." Eight participants is a very small sample, and the 2022 practical guidelines rate the study as level 3 evidence.

What did the graded motor imagery trials find?

Two trials by Moseley reported less pain with graded motor imagery than with usual care. The 2004 trial randomly assigned 13 people with chronic CRPS type I to the program or to ongoing management. The paper reported an effect of about 25 points on the Neuropathic Pain Scale and stated that "the number needed to treat for a 50% reduction in NPS score was approximately 2."

The 2006 trial assigned 51 people with CRPS type I or phantom limb pain to graded motor imagery or to physical therapy and ongoing medical care. Pain fell by 23.4 mm on a 100 mm scale in the motor imagery group and by 10.5 mm in the control group. Improvement in function was similar, and the gains held at six months.

How do the mirror therapy and graded motor imagery studies compare?

Three controlled studies form the core evidence for mirror therapy and graded motor imagery in CRPS, and together they enrolled 72 people. All three were small, and two came from the same researcher.

Controlled studies of mirror therapy and graded motor imagery that enrolled people with CRPS
StudyWho was studiedWhat the study found
McCabe et al., Rheumatology, 2003 (mirror therapy)8 people with CRPS type I for 3 weeks to 3 yearsImmediate pain relief in CRPS of 8 weeks or less; less stiffness in CRPS of up to 1 year; no change in chronic CRPS
Moseley, Pain, 2004 (graded motor imagery)13 people with chronic CRPS type IAbout 25 points lower on the Neuropathic Pain Scale than ongoing management; number needed to treat about 2
Moseley, Neurology, 2006 (graded motor imagery)51 people with CRPS type I or phantom limb painPain fell 23.4 mm with motor imagery and 10.5 mm with usual care on a 100 mm scale; gains held at 6 months

Have later studies confirmed that graded motor imagery works for CRPS?

Later studies have not confirmed the early results. The 2022 practical guidelines report that "somewhat larger follow-up studies found that this graded motor imagery intervention failed to improve pain, and in one study, appeared to increase pain and edema." The guidelines conclude that the value of mirror therapy and graded motor imagery "remains to be proven in definitive trials."

A 2022 Cochrane review of physiotherapy for CRPS by Smart and colleagues included brain-directed rehabilitation among its 34 trials. The review graded the certainty of the evidence as very low for every comparison, citing study limitations, imprecision and inconsistency. The positive trials of graded motor imagery came from one research team.

Does mirror therapy work for long-standing CRPS?

Mirror therapy alone did not help long-standing CRPS in the one study that tested it. McCabe's 2003 pilot found no change in chronic CRPS. Moseley's 2004 paper states that mirror therapy "is not effective for chronic CRPS1, possibly because movement of the limb evokes intolerable pain."

Graded motor imagery was designed to address long-standing CRPS. The two earlier steps, limb recognition and imagined movement, come before the mirror so that the person does not start with movement. The 13 patients in Moseley's 2004 trial all had chronic CRPS type I.

How is a mirror therapy session for CRPS carried out?

A mirror therapy session for CRPS is short and is repeated through the day. The 2022 practical guidelines describe McCabe's protocol. The person first closes the eyes and describes both limbs, then imagines moving both, and then looks at the reflected limb without moving until the reflection feels like the person's own limb. Movements focus on the painful joints and the joints next to them.

The guidelines report that the emphasis is on sessions of no more than five minutes, done five to six times a day, usually as a home program set by a therapist. The guidelines call the published protocols "loose treatment parameters" and say both depend on the therapist watching the patient's response.

When are mirror therapy and graded motor imagery stopped?

The researchers who developed the two programs identified situations in which they should not continue. The 2022 practical guidelines list three: "the inability to establish ownership of the mirrored extremity, increase in pain, and any increase in movement disorders." Ownership means the reflected limb feels like the person's own. A therapist who supervises mirror therapy or graded motor imagery for CRPS watches for all three.

Where do guidelines place mirror therapy and graded motor imagery in CRPS care?

Both major guidelines list mirror therapy and graded motor imagery as rehabilitation techniques for CRPS. The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline includes mirror visual feedback among its therapeutic approaches and graded motor imagery among its examples of rehabilitation techniques developed for CRPS. The 2022 practical guidelines place the two therapies early in occupational therapy, before swelling control, desensitization and weight bearing, which are described in physical and occupational therapy for CRPS.

Common questions

No. Mirror therapy is one technique: watching the reflection of the unaffected limb move. Graded motor imagery is a three-step program in which mirror therapy is the last step. The first two steps are judging whether pictured limbs are left or right and imagining movements without moving. Moseley designed the sequence for long-standing CRPS, in which moving the limb in front of a mirror can be too painful to begin with.

Moseley's program runs six weeks, with two weeks in each of the three steps, according to the 2022 practical guidelines in Pain Medicine. In his 2006 trial of 51 patients with CRPS type I or phantom limb pain, the reduction in pain measured at the end of the program was maintained at the six-month follow-up. Therapists adjust the pace to the person's response.

Mirror therapy is often set up as a home program between appointments. The 2022 practical guidelines describe a home program of short sessions, no more than five minutes, repeated five to six times a day. The guidelines also say the published protocols depend on a therapist observing symptoms and response, and that an increase in pain or movement problems is a reason to stop. A therapist normally teaches the method first.

It can in some people. The 2022 practical guidelines report that in one follow-up study, graded motor imagery appeared to increase pain and swelling. The developers of the programs listed increased pain and increased movement disorders as reasons to stop. A person with CRPS whose pain rises during mirror therapy or motor imagery should report it to the therapist.

Yes. The 2022 practical guidelines credit Ramachandran with first describing the use of mirrors to reduce pain in people with phantom limb pain after amputation. Moseley's 2006 trial of graded motor imagery enrolled people with phantom limb pain together with people with CRPS type I. The trial found an effect of treatment group on pain and function and no effect of which diagnosis the person had.

Researchers have tested it. The 2022 practical guidelines describe a controlled pilot study of virtual reality feedback that followed the person's own movements, called virtual body swapping. The treatment produced short-term improvement in how people with CRPS perceived the affected body part and did not significantly change pain. The guidelines rate the study as level 3 evidence and say the value of the approach remains to be proven.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: Practical Diagnostic and Treatment Guidelines, 5th EditionClinical guideline · Pain Medicine (Harden et al.), 2022 · checked
  2. Complex regional pain syndrome in adults: UK guidelines for diagnosis, referral and management in primary and secondary care, 2nd editionClinical guideline · Royal College of Physicians, 2018 · checked
  3. A controlled pilot study of the utility of mirror visual feedback in the treatment of complex regional pain syndrome (type 1)Study · Rheumatology (McCabe et al.), 2003 · checked
  4. Graded motor imagery is effective for long-standing complex regional pain syndrome: a randomised controlled trialStudy · Pain (Moseley), 2004 · checked
  5. Graded motor imagery for pathologic pain: a randomized controlled trialStudy · Neurology (Moseley), 2006 · checked
  6. Physiotherapy for pain and disability in adults with complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) types I and IIStudy · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Smart et al.), 2022 · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall