Which experts testify in a CRPS case?

A California complex regional pain syndrome case usually rests on medical expert testimony from a pain medicine physician, often joined by a neurologist, a rehabilitation physician, a psychologist, a life care planner and an economist. California requires expert testimony to prove medical causation, and the judge screens each expert opinion under Sargon Enterprises v. University of Southern California.

Painted scales of justice holding a poppy and lupine.

Why does a CRPS case in California require medical expert testimony?

California law requires expert testimony to prove that an injury caused a medical condition. In Jones v. Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp., a published 1985 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, the court wrote, "The law is well settled that in a personal injury action causation must be proven within a reasonable medical probability based upon competent expert testimony. Mere possibility alone is insufficient to establish a prima facie case."

Complex regional pain syndrome adds a second medical question, which is whether the diagnosis is correct. Both questions are answered by physicians.

Which medical experts testify in a CRPS case, and what does each one cover?

Most California CRPS cases use treating doctors for what they observed and retained witnesses for the opinions the treating doctors did not form. The mix depends on what the defense disputes.

Witnesses commonly called in a California CRPS case and what each addresses
WitnessWhat the witness addresses in a CRPS case
Pain medicine physicianThe CRPS diagnosis under the Budapest criteria, response to treatment, and outlook
NeurologistNerve testing for CRPS type II and the exclusion of other nerve conditions
Physical medicine and rehabilitation physicianFunction, rehabilitation, equipment and the medical basis for future care
Orthopedic or hand surgeonThe original injury and how it would normally have healed
Psychologist or psychiatristDepression, anxiety and the claim that the pain is psychological
Life care plannerThe list and cost of future care that physicians say is needed
Vocational rehabilitation witnessWhether the person can work, and at what
EconomistThe present value of future care and lost earnings

What is the difference between a treating doctor and a retained expert witness?

A treating doctor examined the patient to provide care, and a retained expert witness was hired by one side to give opinions for the lawsuit. The treating doctors hold the most direct evidence in a complex regional pain syndrome case, because they saw the color, temperature and swelling changes when they happened.

California regulates how retained witnesses are disclosed. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 2034.210, after the first trial date is set, any party may demand a simultaneous exchange of the names of the people whose expert opinion each side expects to offer at trial. A witness retained to form an opinion for the litigation must be listed with an expert witness declaration.

What can a California judge exclude under Sargon?

A California judge decides whether an expert opinion is reliable enough for the jury to hear. In Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California, a published 2012 opinion, the Supreme Court of California held that "the trial court acts as a gatekeeper to exclude expert opinion testimony" in three situations. The opinion is excluded when it is "based on matter of a type on which an expert may not reasonably rely," when its reasons are unsupported by the material the witness relies on, or when it is "speculative."

The rule applies to both sides of a CRPS case. A physician who predicts a future amputation without support in the records risks exclusion under Sargon, and so does a defense engineer who offers a medical opinion about what an impact could cause.

What does People v. Sanchez mean for an expert witness in a CRPS case?

People v. Sanchez limits what an expert witness may tell the jury about facts the witness did not observe. The Supreme Court of California's published 2016 opinion states, "Case-specific facts are those relating to the particular events and participants alleged to have been involved in the case being tried." An expert witness may rely on hearsay in forming an opinion but may not relate case-specific hearsay as true unless it is independently proved or falls within an exception.

For complex regional pain syndrome, the rule means a retained physician cannot simply recite other doctors' chart notes about skin color and temperature. The treating providers who saw those signs, or properly authenticated records, must put them in evidence first.

Is a medical expert opinion enough if it only states a conclusion?

No. A California court requires the reasoning behind a medical expert opinion. In Fernandez v. Alexander, a published 2019 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, a patient whose wrist fracture was treated with a cast sued the doctor, and the records noted "questionable mild RSD." The court affirmed summary judgment for the doctor because the patient's medical expert declared that the choice of a cast caused the worse result without explaining why.

An unpublished opinion shows the same point. In Yoder v. Okhovat, a 2023 unpublished opinion of the same court, an unsworn letter from a treating doctor saying the symptoms were "consistent with" CRPS did not create a triable issue on causation.

Does a medical expert witness have to rule out every other cause of CRPS?

No. California's substantial factor test does not require certainty. In Cooper v. Takeda Pharmaceuticals America, Inc., a published 2015 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, Second District, the trial court struck a physician who had reached his causation opinion by differential diagnosis, the method of listing possible causes and excluding them. The Court of Appeal reversed.

The Cooper court wrote that "it is not necessary for a plaintiff to establish the negligence of the defendant as the proximate cause of injury with absolute certainty so as to exclude every other possible cause of a plaintiff's illness." Cooper involved a drug and bladder cancer. Its reasoning applies when a defense argues that CRPS might have arisen without the injury.

Who testifies about future care and lost earnings in a CRPS case?

A life care planner, a vocational witness and an economist present the future losses, and each depends on a physician. CACI No. 3903A allows future medical expenses only for care the plaintiff "is reasonably certain to need in the future," so a doctor must support each item in a life care plan. Under People v. Sanchez, the planner cannot supply that support by repeating what a doctor said outside court.

CACI No. 3903D covers lost earning capacity and requires proof that it is reasonably certain the injury will cause the plaintiff to earn less in the future. The guide to the life care plan describes the future care evidence.

Which experts testify for the defense in a CRPS case?

Insurers commonly retain a physician to examine the injured person and testify that the Budapest criteria are not met. Code of Civil Procedure section 2032.220 allows any defendant to demand one physical examination of a plaintiff who seeks recovery for personal injuries. The defense medical exam guide covers the limits on that examination.

Defendants also commonly call a psychiatrist or psychologist to attribute the pain to a psychological cause, and in vehicle cases an engineer to describe the forces of the collision. The same Sargon and Sanchez rules apply to each defense witness in a complex regional pain syndrome case.

Can a treating doctor's testimony hurt the causation case?

Yes. A treating doctor answers under oath and may not share the opinion the claim needs. In Gin v. Pennsylvania Life Ins. Co., a published 2005 opinion of the California Court of Appeal, the treating pain physician was asked the cause of the plaintiff's complex regional pain syndrome and answered that "no one has an explanation all the time as to what precipitates this neuropathic injury."

The Gin court held that repetitive keyboard work was not an "accidental bodily injury" under an accident-only disability policy. The case shows why lawyers learn each treating doctor's actual opinion on the cause of CRPS before relying on that doctor.

Can the defense use its witnesses to blame the treating doctors for CRPS?

A defendant may argue that treating doctors caused or worsened the condition, and that defense needs proof of its own. In Allphin v. Peter K. Fitness, LLC, a 2015 decision of the federal district court for the Northern District of California published in the Federal Supplement, an exercise band snapped and the plaintiff was diagnosed with CRPS type I. The court granted the plaintiff partial summary judgment on the defense that her doctors' malpractice should absorb part of the damages.

California's CACI No. 3929 also makes the original wrongdoer responsible for additional harm from medical treatment the injury reasonably required, "even if those acts were negligently performed."

Common questions

A treating pain physician is usually the most important medical witness in a complex regional pain syndrome case, because that doctor examined the limb over time and recorded the signs. Whether the same doctor also gives every opinion the case needs depends on what the doctor believes about the cause and the future. In Gin v. Pennsylvania Life Ins. Co., a published 2005 California Court of Appeal opinion, a treating pain physician's candid answer about the cause of CRPS weakened the plaintiff's position.

Reasonable medical probability is a higher standard than possibility. The California Court of Appeal explained in Jones v. Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp., a published 1985 opinion, that there is a distinction between a reasonable medical probability and a medical possibility, and that mere possibility alone is insufficient. A doctor who testifies that an injury could have caused CRPS has not met the standard. The doctor must explain why the injury probably did.

No. California state courts apply Evidence Code sections 801 and 802 as interpreted in Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California, a published 2012 opinion of the Supreme Court of California. Under Sargon, the trial judge acts as a gatekeeper and excludes expert opinion testimony that rests on matter an expert may not reasonably rely on, on reasons the material does not support, or on speculation.

Each side pays the witnesses it retains. In a contingency fee case the law firm usually advances those costs, and the written fee agreement states who bears them if there is no recovery. The firm that publishes this site states its terms this way: if there is no recovery, you owe no fee and no case costs.

Insurers commonly argue that the pain comes from a psychological condition instead of the injury. A 2008 Dutch study by de Mos and colleagues, comparing 186 people with CRPS to 697 controls, reported that psychological factors were not associated with CRPS onset. California law also addresses the argument: CACI No. 3928 requires full compensation for a person who was more susceptible to injury than a normally healthy person would have been.

Not effectively. CACI No. 3903A limits future medical expenses to care the plaintiff is reasonably certain to need, which is a medical judgment. Under People v. Sanchez, a published 2016 opinion of the Supreme Court of California, a witness may not relate case-specific hearsay as true, so a planner cannot establish medical need by repeating a doctor's out-of-court statement. A physician must testify to the need for each kind of care.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Jones v. Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp. (1985) 163 Cal.App.3d 396Court opinion · California Court of Appeal (published), 1985 · checked
  2. Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747Court opinion · Supreme Court of California (published), 2012 · checked
  3. People v. Sanchez (2016) 63 Cal.4th 665Court opinion · Supreme Court of California (published), 2016 · checked
  4. Fernandez v. Alexander (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 770Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District (published), 2019 · checked
  5. Yoder v. Okhovat (Aug. 24, 2023, B320945)Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District, Division One (unpublished), 2023 · checked
  6. Cooper v. Takeda Pharmaceuticals America, Inc. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 555Court opinion · California Court of Appeal, Second District (published), 2015 · checked
  7. Gin v. Pennsylvania Life Ins. Co. (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 939Court opinion · California Court of Appeal (published), 2005 · checked
  8. Allphin v. Peter K. Fitness, LLC (N.D. Cal. 2015) 78 F.Supp.3d 987Court opinion · United States District Court, Northern District of California (published in the Federal Supplement), 2015 · checked
  9. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 editionJury instruction · Judicial Council of California, 2026 · checked
  10. Code of Civil Procedure section 2034.210Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  11. Code of Civil Procedure section 2032.220Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  12. Validation of proposed diagnostic criteria (the "Budapest Criteria") for Complex Regional Pain SyndromeStudy · Pain (Harden et al.), 2010 · checked
  13. Medical history and the onset of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS)Study · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2008 · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall