How often does CRPS follow a broken wrist?

Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) followed 3.8 percent of wrist fractures treated without surgery in the largest prospective study, which examined 1,549 patients in 2014. A second 2014 study found CRPS after 8.8 percent of 477 surgically treated wrist fractures. A 2023 meta-analysis of nine studies reported rates from 0.19 to 13.63 percent.

A painted pair of crutches tied with an orange ribbon among poppies.

What do the largest studies of CRPS after a wrist fracture show?

The two largest prospective studies put the rate of CRPS after a wrist fracture between about 4 and 9 percent. Moseley and colleagues (2014) assessed 1,549 patients whose wrist fractures were managed without surgery at three hospital fracture clinics. CRPS developed within four months in 3.8 percent, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 2.9 to 4.8 percent. The authors summarized the finding as "one in 26 patients."

Roh and colleagues (2014) followed 477 patients for six months after surgery for a distal radius fracture, the most common kind of broken wrist. Forty-two patients, or 8.8 percent, met the Budapest research criteria for CRPS type I.

Why do studies of CRPS after a wrist fracture report such different rates?

Studies of CRPS after a wrist fracture report different rates because they use different diagnostic criteria, methods and sample sizes. Beerthuizen and colleagues (2012) applied three sets of criteria to the same 596 fracture patients and counted 7.0 percent, 21.3 percent or 48.5 percent as having CRPS type I depending on the set. Small studies also produce wide swings, and insurance claims count only cases that received a diagnosis code. A 2023 meta-analysis of nine studies by Lorente and colleagues found rates from 0.19 to 13.63 percent.

What rate of CRPS did each wrist fracture study find?

Published studies of CRPS after a wrist fracture report rates from 0.19 percent to 32.2 percent. The table lists each study with its patients and method.

Published rates of CRPS after a wrist fracture, by study
StudyPatients and methodRate of CRPS after a wrist fracture
Moseley and colleagues, 20141,549 fractures treated without surgery, examined3.8 percent within 4 months
Roh and colleagues, 2014477 fractures treated with surgery; Budapest research criteria8.8 percent within 6 months
Beerthuizen and colleagues, 2012596 Dutch patients with wrist, ankle or foot fractures; Harden and Bruehl criteria7.0 percent
Dijkstra and colleagues, 200388 fractures at a Dutch emergency unit1 percent (1 patient)
Dilek and colleagues, 201250 fractures treated in casts in Turkey26 percent
Jellad and colleagues, 201490 fractures treated in casts in Tunisia32.2 percent
Zollinger and colleagues, 1999 and 2007Placebo groups of two Dutch vitamin C trials22 percent in 1999; 10.1 percent in 2007
Crijns and colleagues, 201859,765 patients in United States insurance claims; diagnosis codes only0.19 percent

Which wrist fractures carry a higher risk of CRPS?

More complex wrist fractures carried a higher risk of CRPS in most studies. Roh and colleagues (2014) found that women and patients with a high-energy injury or a severe fracture type were significantly more likely to develop CRPS type I after wrist surgery. Beerthuizen and colleagues (2012) found more CRPS after intra-articular fractures, which extend into the joint, and after fracture dislocations.

Crijns and colleagues (2018) reported an odds ratio of 1.54 when the ulna was broken along with the radius. One study points the other way: Jellad and colleagues (2014) found higher risk after medium and low-energy trauma among 90 patients treated in casts. Fracture severity shifts the odds and does not decide the outcome.

Does severe pain in the first week after a wrist fracture predict CRPS?

Yes, strongly, in the one large study that tested it. Moseley and colleagues (2014) assessed 1,549 patients within one week of a wrist fracture and found that a single pain rating from 0 to 10 separated those who later developed CRPS from those who did not almost as well as a four-part clinical model. The authors concluded that a pain score of 5 or more in the first week "should be considered a 'red flag' for CRPS."

Jellad and colleagues (2014) likewise found that a high pain score on a wrist questionnaire predicted CRPS, with an odds ratio of 12.19. Unusual early pain after a wrist fracture is a reason to tell the treating doctor.

When does CRPS appear after a wrist fracture?

CRPS usually appears within weeks of a wrist fracture, often soon after the cast comes off. Jellad and colleagues (2014) recorded CRPS a mean of 21.7 days after cast removal, with a standard deviation of 23.7 days, and concluded that CRPS "occurs frequently during the third and fourth week after cast removal."

The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline states that the onset of symptoms "for the majority occurs within 1 month of the trauma or immobilisation of the limb," and that CRPS "can often not be reliably diagnosed before 4 weeks after injury." Follow-up visits in the first two months after a wrist fracture are when the condition is usually first seen.

Does surgery on a broken wrist raise the risk of CRPS?

The published studies do not show whether surgery on a broken wrist raises the risk of CRPS. The 8.8 percent rate after surgery (Roh, 2014) is higher than the 3.8 percent rate without surgery (Moseley, 2014), but the two studies used different criteria and follow-up periods, and fractures that need surgery are usually more severe.

The 2023 meta-analysis by Lorente and colleagues reported that the type of surgery, external fixation or internal fixation with a plate, was not a risk factor. In Danish compensation records, surgical treatment was associated with approval of a CRPS claim, with an odds ratio of 3.5 (Petersen and colleagues, 2018). That figure describes compensation claims for all conditions, not wrist fractures alone.

Does a cast on a broken wrist affect the risk of CRPS?

Problems with the cast were linked to CRPS in three studies of wrist fractures. In the 2007 trial by Zollinger and colleagues of 416 patients, early cast-related complaints predicted CRPS with a relative risk of 5.35 (95 percent confidence interval 2.13 to 13.42). Field and colleagues (1994) measured cast tightness weekly in 23 patients and found tighter casts during the first three weeks in the six who developed the condition.

Dijkstra and colleagues (2003) found that cast changes and pain during the cast period played a minor role among 88 patients. The page on casts and CRPS covers the evidence in full.

Do people recover from CRPS after a wrist fracture?

Many people with CRPS after a fracture improve during the first year, and a complete return to normal is less certain. A 2015 review in The BMJ by Bruehl states that "many cases resolve within the first year, with a smaller subset progressing to the chronic form." Beerthuizen and colleagues (2012) reported that none of their 42 patients with CRPS type I after a fracture was free of symptoms at 12 months.

The two statements measure different things: no longer meeting the diagnostic criteria, and having no symptoms at all. The page on whether CRPS goes away compares the recovery studies.

Can vitamin C prevent CRPS after a broken wrist?

Trials of vitamin C after a wrist fracture disagree. Zollinger and colleagues reported less CRPS with vitamin C in two Dutch trials: 7 percent against 22 percent with placebo in 1999, and 2.4 percent against 10.1 percent in 2007. Ekrol and colleagues (2014) randomized 336 patients in a third trial and concluded that vitamin C "confers no benefit."

The 2022 practical guidelines by Harden and colleagues state that the usefulness of vitamin C for prevention "remains unproven." The page on preventing CRPS after a fracture sets out each trial and the guideline positions.

What does CRPS after a broken wrist mean for a California claim?

When someone else's conduct caused the fall or crash that broke the wrist, California law treats CRPS that follows as part of the harm from that event. The standard jury instruction on susceptible plaintiffs, CACI No. 3928, directs full compensation "even if a normally healthy person would not have suffered similar injury." The claimant must still prove that the injury was a substantial factor in causing the CRPS, which is the test in CACI No. 430.

Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 allows two years for most injury lawsuits, and a claim against a public entity must be presented within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Both periods generally run from the injury, not from the CRPS diagnosis. See CRPS after a fall on someone's property, CRPS after a car accident and how causation is proved.

Common questions

A Colles fracture is a break of the radius near the wrist, and it is the injury most CRPS fracture studies examine. Rates in prospective studies of distal radius fractures run from 1 percent (Dijkstra, 2003, 88 patients) to 32.2 percent (Jellad, 2014, 90 patients), with the largest studies at 3.8 and 8.8 percent. Atkins and colleagues (1990) found that 24 of 60 patients had unstable blood flow in the hand nine weeks after a Colles fracture, which shows that single CRPS features are far more common than the full diagnosis.

Pain that grows instead of easing after a wrist fracture has several possible explanations, and CRPS is one of them. Moseley and colleagues (2014) called a pain score of 5 or more out of 10 in the first week a red flag for CRPS. The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline lists other causes a doctor must exclude, including infection, a poorly fixed fracture, nerve compression and compartment syndrome, some of which need urgent treatment. A doctor's examination is the only way to tell them apart.

Yes, in nearly every study. Roh and colleagues (2014) found female sex to be an independent predictor of CRPS type I after wrist surgery. Crijns and colleagues (2018) reported an odds ratio of 3.86 for women in United States insurance claims, and Jellad and colleagues (2014) reported 5.77. In the 2007 vitamin C trial by Zollinger and colleagues, every patient who developed CRPS was an elderly woman. Atkins and colleagues (1990) found no association with sex among 60 patients.

The answer depends on how cases are counted. In United States insurance claims from 2012 to 2014, only 114 of 59,765 distal radius fracture patients, or 0.19 percent, received a CRPS diagnosis code (Crijns and colleagues, 2018). Studies that examined every patient found far more: 3.8 percent without surgery (Moseley, 2014) and 8.8 percent with surgery (Roh, 2014). A claims figure counts only the cases that a doctor diagnosed and coded.

Studies conflict. Dilek and colleagues (2012) followed 50 patients and found more CRPS in those with high trait anxiety scores. Dijkstra and colleagues (2003) assessed life events and psychological history in 88 patients and concluded that such risk factors play a minor role. A Dutch case-control study of 186 people with CRPS and 697 controls by de Mos and colleagues (2008) reported that "psychological factors were not associated with CRPS onset."

The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline states that CRPS "can often not be reliably diagnosed before 4 weeks after injury," because pain, swelling and color change are also part of normal healing in the first weeks. The guideline adds that continuing symptoms in that period may indicate that a patient is at risk, and that emergency physicians may arrange a follow-up visit more than four weeks after the injury to allow a definite diagnosis.

A healed fracture does not end a California injury claim when CRPS followed the injury. Pain that continues after the tissue has healed, out of proportion to the original injury, is the first of the Budapest diagnostic criteria. CACI No. 430 asks whether the defendant's conduct was a substantial factor in causing the harm, and CACI No. 3928 covers harm that a normally healthy person would not have suffered. Medical records showing when the CRPS signs began connect the two.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Intense pain soon after wrist fracture strongly predicts who will develop complex regional pain syndrome: prospective cohort studyStudy · The Journal of Pain (Moseley et al.), 2014 · checked
  2. Factors associated with complex regional pain syndrome type I in patients with surgically treated distal radius fractureStudy · Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (Roh et al.), 2014 · checked
  3. Incidence and risk factors for complex regional pain syndrome in radius fractures: meta-analysisStudy · Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (Lorente et al.), 2023 · checked
  4. Demographic and medical parameters in the development of complex regional pain syndrome type 1 (CRPS1): prospective study on 596 patients with a fractureStudy · Pain (Beerthuizen et al.), 2012 · checked
  5. Incidence of complex regional pain syndrome type I after fractures of the distal radiusStudy · European Journal of Pain (Dijkstra et al.), 2003 · checked
  6. Anxious personality is a risk factor for developing complex regional pain syndrome type IStudy · Rheumatology International (Dilek et al.), 2012 · checked
  7. Complex regional pain syndrome type I: incidence and risk factors in patients with fracture of the distal radiusStudy · Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (Jellad et al.), 2014 · checked
  8. Effect of vitamin C on frequency of reflex sympathetic dystrophy in wrist fractures: a randomised trialStudy · The Lancet (Zollinger et al.), 1999 · checked
  9. Can vitamin C prevent complex regional pain syndrome in patients with wrist fractures? A randomized, controlled, multicenter dose-response studyStudy · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, American Volume (Zollinger et al.), 2007 · checked
  10. The influence of vitamin C on the outcome of distal radial fractures: a double-blind, randomized controlled trialStudy · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, American Volume (Ekrol et al.), 2014 · checked
  11. Complex Regional Pain Syndrome After Distal Radius Fracture Is Uncommon and Is Often Associated With FibromyalgiaStudy · Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research (Crijns et al.), 2018 · checked
  12. Algodystrophy after Colles fractures is associated with secondary tightness of castsStudy · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, British Volume (Field et al.), 1994 · checked
  13. Features of algodystrophy after Colles' fractureStudy · The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, British Volume (Atkins et al.), 1990 · checked
  14. Risk Factors for Post-treatment Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS): An Analysis of 647 Cases of CRPS from the Danish Patient Compensation AssociationStudy · Pain Practice (Petersen et al.), 2018 · checked
  15. Complex regional pain syndromeStudy · The BMJ (Bruehl), 2015 · checked
  16. Medical history and the onset of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS)Study · Pain (de Mos et al.), 2008 · checked
  17. Complex regional pain syndrome in adults: UK guidelines for diagnosis, referral and management in primary and secondary care, 2nd editionClinical guideline · Royal College of Physicians, 2018 · checked
  18. Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: Practical Diagnostic and Treatment Guidelines, 5th EditionClinical guideline · Pain Medicine (Harden et al.), 2022 · checked
  19. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 editionJury instruction · Judicial Council of California, 2026 · checked
  20. Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  21. Government Code section 911.2Statute · California Legislative Information · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall