CRPS after a blood draw, IV or injection

Complex regional pain syndrome has been reported after blood draws, IV placement and injections, and the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke lists needle sticks among its rare causes. The evidence consists of case reports and small case series. No study has measured how often CRPS follows a needle procedure, so no rate can be given.

A painted pair of crutches tied with an orange ribbon among poppies.

Can a blood draw, IV or injection cause CRPS?

Yes, though published reports are few. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke lists needle sticks among the rare causes of complex regional pain syndrome. Medical journals contain reports of CRPS after venipuncture (the medical term for puncturing a vein with a needle, as in a blood draw or an IV start) and after injections, including vaccinations.

A 2014 case report and literature review from the University of Iowa (Elahi and Reddy, Case Reports in Medicine) describes venipuncture as "the most frequently performed invasive medical procedure" and as "usually benign." The same paper observes that the triggering event in CRPS "can often seem far too trivial" for the condition that follows.

How often does CRPS follow a needle procedure?

Nobody knows, because no study has measured it. The research reviewed for this page found no incidence figure for CRPS after a blood draw, an IV or an injection. The published evidence is limited to case reports, which describe one patient, and case series, which describe a handful of patients gathered by one author.

Case reports show that an outcome has happened. They cannot show how often the outcome happens, because nobody counted the procedures that went without incident. Elahi and Reddy wrote in 2014 that "there is not adequate medical knowledge about this important subject" and that these patients "raise many unanswerable questions regarding incidence, predisposition, and causation." A percentage for needle-related CRPS could not be traced to any study reviewed for this page.

The published literature on needle-related CRPS is made up of single cases and small series. The table lists four publications reviewed for this page. None is a study of incidence.

Published reports of CRPS after needle procedures, with the number of patients in each
PublicationType of evidenceWhat it reports
Horowitz, Transfusion, 2000Case series of 24 patients, plus dissection of 14 arms from seven cadaversNerve-injury CRPS (causalgia) after routine venipuncture: 11 patients first reported in 1994 and 13 additional patients
Elahi and Reddy, Case Reports in Medicine, 2014One case, with a literature reviewA 52-year-old teacher whose arm pain began during a routine blood draw at the inner elbow and was diagnosed as CRPS
Richards and colleagues, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 2012Case series of five adolescents in AustraliaCRPS type I after immunization: four cases after human papillomavirus vaccine and one after a diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis vaccine
Hirata, Hand Surgery, 2014Review prompted by a court case in JapanA Japanese lawsuit over CRPS after an injection needle stick, with a review of the research

How can a needle injure a nerve during a blood draw?

A needle can touch a skin nerve because the nerves of the arm run beside, over and under the veins used for blood draws. Horowitz dissected 14 arms from seven cadavers at three common venipuncture sites in a study published in Transfusion in 2000. Major branches of skin nerves lay on top of the veins in six of the 14 arms, and in many places nerves and veins were intertwined.

Horowitz concluded that "needle-nerve contact during venipuncture is common." Because lasting nerve injury after a blood draw is rare, the paper reasoned that "factors other than direct nerve contact appear necessary for the chronic pain syndrome to occur." Contact between a needle and a nerve does not, on this evidence, lead to CRPS in most people.

Does CRPS after a blood draw mean the procedure was done wrong?

Not necessarily. The Horowitz series describes both situations. In the 11 patients first reported in 1994, the nerve injury appeared to result from direct trauma when the needle, or injected material, entered the layer where the nerves lie. In 3 of the 13 additional patients, the venipunctures were described as properly performed and atraumatic.

Elahi and Reddy, citing earlier reports, describe nerve injury after venipuncture as reportedly rare, in the range of 1 in 21,000 to 1 in 26,700 procedures. That range counts nerve injuries of all kinds and is not a rate of CRPS, and the review does not describe the populations behind it. The case literature does not establish that needle-related CRPS always, or usually, reflects poor technique.

Is CRPS after a needle stick type I or type II?

Reports describe both types. CRPS type I was formerly called reflex sympathetic dystrophy (RSD); type II was formerly called causalgia. Type II follows an identified injury to a specific nerve. The 11 patients Horowitz first reported in 1994 all developed causalgia, meaning type II, and the 2000 paper presents the full series of 24 under the title of venipuncture-induced causalgia.

The five adolescents in the 2012 Australian immunization series were described as having CRPS type I, with no identified nerve injury. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke notes that nerve conduction studies "can detect nerve injuries linked to CRPS type 2 but usually cannot confirm CRPS type 1." A normal nerve study after a needle stick therefore does not settle whether a person has CRPS.

What does CRPS after a blood draw look like in a published case?

In the one case Elahi and Reddy describe in detail, pain started at the moment of the blood draw. A 52-year-old teacher with no significant medical history had blood drawn at the left inner elbow for a cholesterol test, and the phlebotomist had difficulty. She said that when the needle went in, it felt like being "electrocuted."

A burning, shooting pain spread from the thumb to the whole hand over the following period. The report records redness, bluish discoloration, a temperature difference between the arms, and pain from light touch. Medications, physical therapy and nerve blocks gave little relief; a spinal cord stimulator helped the arm, and symptoms later appeared in a leg. One case shows what can happen and does not show what is typical.

Has CRPS been reported after a vaccination?

Yes, in a small number of published cases. Richards and colleagues reported five adolescents in Australia with CRPS type I after immunization in Archives of Disease in Childhood in 2012. Four cases followed human papillomavirus vaccine and one followed a diphtheria, tetanus and acellular pertussis vaccine. The authors also noted earlier reports after rubella and hepatitis B vaccines.

A case series of five patients cannot show that a vaccine, or the needle, caused the condition, and it gives no rate. The authors' stated purpose was awareness, so that CRPS in a young person is recognized and treated promptly.

Why is CRPS after a needle procedure often recognized late?

Needle-related CRPS is recognized late because the procedure seems too minor to explain severe pain. Elahi and Reddy wrote that nerve pain after venipuncture "is hard to recognize at an early stage," and that practicing physicians have little information to help them identify it early.

A Dutch study of 537 CRPS patients (de Rooij and colleagues, 2010) suggested that cases without a clear starting event may be diagnosed later because of reluctance to make the diagnosis in the absence of a clear initiating event. The Royal College of Physicians' 2018 guideline states that patients "commonly experience a delay in diagnosis." A person with burning pain, color change or swelling that persists after a needle procedure should see a doctor.

What do the medical facts mean for a California claim after a needle injury?

The medical literature shows that CRPS can follow a needle procedure, and it also shows that this can happen when the procedure was performed properly. The condition alone does not establish that a health care provider did anything wrong. California's jury instruction on the point, CACI No. 505, says a medical practitioner "is not necessarily negligent just because" the practitioner's efforts are unsuccessful. A claim depends on what was done in the particular procedure, measured against the standard of care.

The deadlines are short. A medical negligence claim must be filed within three years of the injury or one year of discovery, whichever comes first, under Code of Civil Procedure section 340.5, with 90 days' notice under section 364. Noneconomic damages in such a case are capped at $470,000 for an injury in 2026 (Civil Code section 3333.2). The page on needle injury claims explains how these cases are evaluated.

Common questions

No study has measured it, so there is no percentage to give. The evidence for CRPS after a blood draw is made up of case reports and small case series, the largest of which describes 24 patients collected by one author (Horowitz, Transfusion, 2000). Venipuncture is described in the medical literature as the most frequently performed invasive medical procedure, and published cases of CRPS after it are few.

It can be a sign that the needle touched a nerve. In the 2014 case report by Elahi and Reddy, the patient described feeling "electrocuted" when the needle went in, and her pain continued afterward. A dissection study by Horowitz concluded that needle contact with a nerve during venipuncture is common and that lasting injury is rare. Pain, burning or numbness that persists after a blood draw is a reason to see a doctor.

The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke lists needle sticks among the rare causes of CRPS, and the published case reports concern needles placed in the veins of the arm. No report specific to an IV line was reviewed for this page, and no study has counted how often CRPS follows an IV. The skin nerves of the arm run close to the veins, which is how a needle or catheter can reach a nerve.

A nerve conduction study can document an injury to a specific nerve, which supports a diagnosis of CRPS type II. It cannot confirm CRPS type I. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke states that these tests can detect nerve injuries linked to CRPS type 2 but usually cannot confirm CRPS type 1. Doctors diagnose CRPS by examination using the Budapest criteria, not by a test result.

When the claim is for medical negligence, Code of Civil Procedure section 340.5 requires filing within three years of the injury or one year of discovery, whichever comes first, with 90 days' notice to the provider under section 364. The one-year period runs from when the person discovers, or through reasonable diligence should have discovered, the injury, which can be before CRPS is diagnosed. A lawyer can calculate the dates for a specific case.

No. A 2014 article in the journal Hand Surgery (Hirata) discussed a Japanese lawsuit over CRPS after an injection needle stick, in which a high court ordered compensation after a lower court had rejected the claim. The decision has no legal force in California. It is listed on this page because the article shows the medical question has been disputed in court, and because it reviews the research.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. The date is when it was last checked.

  1. Venipuncture-induced complex regional pain syndrome: a case report and review of the literatureStudy · Case Reports in Medicine (Elahi and Reddy), 2014 · checked
  2. Venipuncture-induced causalgia: anatomic relations of upper extremity superficial veins and nerves, and clinical considerationsStudy · Transfusion (Horowitz), 2000 · checked
  3. Complex regional pain syndrome following immunisationStudy · Archives of Disease in Childhood (Richards et al.), 2012 · checked
  4. How big of a threat is needlestick-injury-induced complex regional pain syndrome? A "scientific" perspectiveStudy · Hand Surgery (Hirata), 2014 · checked
  5. Spontaneous onset of complex regional pain syndromeStudy · European Journal of Pain (de Rooij et al.), 2010 · checked
  6. Complex Regional Pain SyndromeGovernment agency · National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke · checked
  7. Complex regional pain syndrome in adults: UK guidelines for diagnosis, referral and management in primary and secondary care, 2nd editionClinical guideline · Royal College of Physicians, 2018 · checked
  8. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 edition: No. 505Jury instruction · Judicial Council of California, 2026 · checked
  9. Code of Civil Procedure section 340.5Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  10. Code of Civil Procedure section 364Statute · California Legislative Information · checked
  11. Civil Code section 3333.2Statute · California Legislative Information · checked

Ask a lawyer about your CRPS case

Free case review. No fee unless we recover. A person from Wise Law reads every message.

What happened before the CRPS started? (optional)
Has a doctor diagnosed CRPS? (optional)
Or call (424) 235-7879

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only by a signed written fee agreement.

Text usCall